Be A Freedom Fighter · Bill Library
HR 10737 — Establishing Gold Standard Science Act
Freedom score: -3 (scale −10 to +10)
- Individual rights: -1
- Property rights: 0
- Economic freedom: 0
- Privacy & due process: -1
- Government power: -1
Sponsor: Rep. Franklin, Scott [R-FL-18] · Latest action: Referred to the House Committee on Science, Space, and Technology. (2026-10-05)
Full text on GovInfo (introduced version) · Congress.gov · ← Bill Library index
Findings — 10 highlighted provisions
Each item below is one provision documented in the findings file. The same provision is highlighted in the full text underneath, with its section citation and criterion. Everything else on this page is plain, unreviewed bill text.
- Sec. 2(b), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(h)(2)–(3) · Individual Rights — Bans federally registered lobbyists from EPA Science Advisory Board appointment and from certain panels involving their lobbying or direct financial interests; disqualifies appointed members from participation in work that evaluates their own research, financial interests, affiliated entities, or those of immediate family. The appointment/participation restrictions are enforced through exclusion and recusal; no new civil or criminal fine is stated See in text ↓
- Sec. 2(c), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(i)(2)(B), (3)–(4) · Individual Rights — Requires appointees to disclose prior professional activities, public statements, expert testimony and representation relevant to advisory work, and update disclosures annually and immediately as specified. This is compelled occupational speech for voluntary appointees; the statutory text states no separate fine See in text ↓
- Sec. 2(d)(1)–(3), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(c)(2), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(d)(2), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(j), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(k) · Individual Rights — Requires EPA Board advice/comments to state reliance on the executive-order-defined Gold Standard Science and weight of evidence; directs the Administrator and chair to seek open exchange and differing viewpoints; creates member allegation, Administrator investigation and mandatory removal/permanent ineligibility upon an affirmative scientific-misconduct determination. No express hearing or appeal is created See in text ↓
- Sec. 2(b), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(h)(4) · Privacy and Due Process — Requires written recusal agreements identifying excluded matters, with prompt public posting by the EPA Administrator; this publishes conflict details about serving appointees See in text ↓
- Sec. 2(c), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(i)(1)–(6) · Privacy and Due Process — Requires original, annual, and immediate written public-disclosure reporting of five-year financial interests, professional work, public statements, relevant federal grants and National Academies participation; EPA annual reports and summaries go to Congress. Expressly provides that past research, grants and professional experience do not by themselves disqualify a member; the scope of public availability of each individual report versus the annual summary is not fully specified See in text ↓
- Sec. 2(d)(3), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(k)(1)–(3) · Privacy and Due Process — Allegations prompt mandatory EPA investigation and decision; a positive finding mandates removal and bars later appointment, without a specifically prescribed notice, hearing or evidentiary standard See in text ↓
- Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions See in text ↓
- Sec. 2(b)–(c) · Government Power — Imposes new EPA nomination/recusal, disclosure administration, public-release, and annual congressional reporting obligations; EPA Administrator standardizes submissions See in text ↓
- Sec. 2(d)(1)–(3) · Government Power — Imposes Board scientific-evidence standards and delegates scientific-misconduct determinations to EPA Administrator, with compulsory removal and future appointment bar See in text ↓
- Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated See in text ↓
Full text (introduced version)
44 of 45 text blocks highlighted. Source: GovInfo, fetched cached.
SECTION 1. SHORT TITLE.
SEC. 2. PROMOTING TRANSPARENCY IN SCIENCE.
Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions
Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated
Sec. 2(b), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(h)(2)–(3) · Individual Rights — Bans federally registered lobbyists from EPA Science Advisory Board appointment and from certain panels involving their lobbying or direct financial interests; disqualifies appointed members from participation in work that evaluates their own research, financial interests, affiliated entities, or those of immediate family. The appointment/participation restrictions are enforced through exclusion and recusal; no new civil or criminal fine is stated
Sec. 2(b), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(h)(4) · Privacy and Due Process — Requires written recusal agreements identifying excluded matters, with prompt public posting by the EPA Administrator; this publishes conflict details about serving appointees
Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions
Sec. 2(b)–(c) · Government Power — Imposes new EPA nomination/recusal, disclosure administration, public-release, and annual congressional reporting obligations; EPA Administrator standardizes submissions
Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated
Sec. 2(b), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(h)(2)–(3) · Individual Rights — Bans federally registered lobbyists from EPA Science Advisory Board appointment and from certain panels involving their lobbying or direct financial interests; disqualifies appointed members from participation in work that evaluates their own research, financial interests, affiliated entities, or those of immediate family. The appointment/participation restrictions are enforced through exclusion and recusal; no new civil or criminal fine is stated
Sec. 2(b), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(h)(4) · Privacy and Due Process — Requires written recusal agreements identifying excluded matters, with prompt public posting by the EPA Administrator; this publishes conflict details about serving appointees
Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions
Sec. 2(b)–(c) · Government Power — Imposes new EPA nomination/recusal, disclosure administration, public-release, and annual congressional reporting obligations; EPA Administrator standardizes submissions
Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated
Sec. 2(b), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(h)(2)–(3) · Individual Rights — Bans federally registered lobbyists from EPA Science Advisory Board appointment and from certain panels involving their lobbying or direct financial interests; disqualifies appointed members from participation in work that evaluates their own research, financial interests, affiliated entities, or those of immediate family. The appointment/participation restrictions are enforced through exclusion and recusal; no new civil or criminal fine is stated
Sec. 2(b), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(h)(4) · Privacy and Due Process — Requires written recusal agreements identifying excluded matters, with prompt public posting by the EPA Administrator; this publishes conflict details about serving appointees
Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions
Sec. 2(b)–(c) · Government Power — Imposes new EPA nomination/recusal, disclosure administration, public-release, and annual congressional reporting obligations; EPA Administrator standardizes submissions
Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated
Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions
Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated
Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions
Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated
Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions
Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated
Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions
Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated
Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions
Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated
Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions
Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated
Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions
Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated
Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions
Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated
Sec. 2(c), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(i)(2)(B), (3)–(4) · Individual Rights — Requires appointees to disclose prior professional activities, public statements, expert testimony and representation relevant to advisory work, and update disclosures annually and immediately as specified. This is compelled occupational speech for voluntary appointees; the statutory text states no separate fine
Sec. 2(c), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(i)(1)–(6) · Privacy and Due Process — Requires original, annual, and immediate written public-disclosure reporting of five-year financial interests, professional work, public statements, relevant federal grants and National Academies participation; EPA annual reports and summaries go to Congress. Expressly provides that past research, grants and professional experience do not by themselves disqualify a member; the scope of public availability of each individual report versus the annual summary is not fully specified
Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions
Sec. 2(b)–(c) · Government Power — Imposes new EPA nomination/recusal, disclosure administration, public-release, and annual congressional reporting obligations; EPA Administrator standardizes submissions
Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated
Sec. 2(c), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(i)(2)(B), (3)–(4) · Individual Rights — Requires appointees to disclose prior professional activities, public statements, expert testimony and representation relevant to advisory work, and update disclosures annually and immediately as specified. This is compelled occupational speech for voluntary appointees; the statutory text states no separate fine
Sec. 2(c), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(i)(1)–(6) · Privacy and Due Process — Requires original, annual, and immediate written public-disclosure reporting of five-year financial interests, professional work, public statements, relevant federal grants and National Academies participation; EPA annual reports and summaries go to Congress. Expressly provides that past research, grants and professional experience do not by themselves disqualify a member; the scope of public availability of each individual report versus the annual summary is not fully specified
Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions
Sec. 2(b)–(c) · Government Power — Imposes new EPA nomination/recusal, disclosure administration, public-release, and annual congressional reporting obligations; EPA Administrator standardizes submissions
Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated
Sec. 2(c), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(i)(2)(B), (3)–(4) · Individual Rights — Requires appointees to disclose prior professional activities, public statements, expert testimony and representation relevant to advisory work, and update disclosures annually and immediately as specified. This is compelled occupational speech for voluntary appointees; the statutory text states no separate fine
Sec. 2(c), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(i)(1)–(6) · Privacy and Due Process — Requires original, annual, and immediate written public-disclosure reporting of five-year financial interests, professional work, public statements, relevant federal grants and National Academies participation; EPA annual reports and summaries go to Congress. Expressly provides that past research, grants and professional experience do not by themselves disqualify a member; the scope of public availability of each individual report versus the annual summary is not fully specified
Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions
Sec. 2(b)–(c) · Government Power — Imposes new EPA nomination/recusal, disclosure administration, public-release, and annual congressional reporting obligations; EPA Administrator standardizes submissions
Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated
Sec. 2(c), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(i)(2)(B), (3)–(4) · Individual Rights — Requires appointees to disclose prior professional activities, public statements, expert testimony and representation relevant to advisory work, and update disclosures annually and immediately as specified. This is compelled occupational speech for voluntary appointees; the statutory text states no separate fine
Sec. 2(c), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(i)(1)–(6) · Privacy and Due Process — Requires original, annual, and immediate written public-disclosure reporting of five-year financial interests, professional work, public statements, relevant federal grants and National Academies participation; EPA annual reports and summaries go to Congress. Expressly provides that past research, grants and professional experience do not by themselves disqualify a member; the scope of public availability of each individual report versus the annual summary is not fully specified
Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions
Sec. 2(b)–(c) · Government Power — Imposes new EPA nomination/recusal, disclosure administration, public-release, and annual congressional reporting obligations; EPA Administrator standardizes submissions
Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated
Sec. 2(c), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(i)(2)(B), (3)–(4) · Individual Rights — Requires appointees to disclose prior professional activities, public statements, expert testimony and representation relevant to advisory work, and update disclosures annually and immediately as specified. This is compelled occupational speech for voluntary appointees; the statutory text states no separate fine
Sec. 2(c), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(i)(1)–(6) · Privacy and Due Process — Requires original, annual, and immediate written public-disclosure reporting of five-year financial interests, professional work, public statements, relevant federal grants and National Academies participation; EPA annual reports and summaries go to Congress. Expressly provides that past research, grants and professional experience do not by themselves disqualify a member; the scope of public availability of each individual report versus the annual summary is not fully specified
Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions
Sec. 2(b)–(c) · Government Power — Imposes new EPA nomination/recusal, disclosure administration, public-release, and annual congressional reporting obligations; EPA Administrator standardizes submissions
Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated
Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions
Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated
Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions
Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated
Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions
Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated
Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions
Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated
Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions
Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated
Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions
Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated
Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions
Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated
Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions
Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated
Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions
Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated
Sec. 2(d)(1)–(3), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(c)(2), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(d)(2), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(j), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(k) · Individual Rights — Requires EPA Board advice/comments to state reliance on the executive-order-defined Gold Standard Science and weight of evidence; directs the Administrator and chair to seek open exchange and differing viewpoints; creates member allegation, Administrator investigation and mandatory removal/permanent ineligibility upon an affirmative scientific-misconduct determination. No express hearing or appeal is created
Sec. 2(d)(3), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(k)(1)–(3) · Privacy and Due Process — Allegations prompt mandatory EPA investigation and decision; a positive finding mandates removal and bars later appointment, without a specifically prescribed notice, hearing or evidentiary standard
Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions
Sec. 2(d)(1)–(3) · Government Power — Imposes Board scientific-evidence standards and delegates scientific-misconduct determinations to EPA Administrator, with compulsory removal and future appointment bar
Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated
Sec. 2(d)(1)–(3), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(c)(2), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(d)(2), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(j), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(k) · Individual Rights — Requires EPA Board advice/comments to state reliance on the executive-order-defined Gold Standard Science and weight of evidence; directs the Administrator and chair to seek open exchange and differing viewpoints; creates member allegation, Administrator investigation and mandatory removal/permanent ineligibility upon an affirmative scientific-misconduct determination. No express hearing or appeal is created
Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions
Sec. 2(d)(1)–(3) · Government Power — Imposes Board scientific-evidence standards and delegates scientific-misconduct determinations to EPA Administrator, with compulsory removal and future appointment bar
Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated
Sec. 2(d)(1)–(3), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(c)(2), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(d)(2), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(j), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(k) · Individual Rights — Requires EPA Board advice/comments to state reliance on the executive-order-defined Gold Standard Science and weight of evidence; directs the Administrator and chair to seek open exchange and differing viewpoints; creates member allegation, Administrator investigation and mandatory removal/permanent ineligibility upon an affirmative scientific-misconduct determination. No express hearing or appeal is created
Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions
Sec. 2(d)(1)–(3) · Government Power — Imposes Board scientific-evidence standards and delegates scientific-misconduct determinations to EPA Administrator, with compulsory removal and future appointment bar
Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated
Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions
Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated
Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions
Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated
Sec. 2(d)(1)–(3), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(c)(2), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(d)(2), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(j), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(k) · Individual Rights — Requires EPA Board advice/comments to state reliance on the executive-order-defined Gold Standard Science and weight of evidence; directs the Administrator and chair to seek open exchange and differing viewpoints; creates member allegation, Administrator investigation and mandatory removal/permanent ineligibility upon an affirmative scientific-misconduct determination. No express hearing or appeal is created
Sec. 2(d)(3), new 42 U.S.C. 4365(k)(1)–(3) · Privacy and Due Process — Allegations prompt mandatory EPA investigation and decision; a positive finding mandates removal and bars later appointment, without a specifically prescribed notice, hearing or evidentiary standard
Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions
Sec. 2(d)(1)–(3) · Government Power — Imposes Board scientific-evidence standards and delegates scientific-misconduct determinations to EPA Administrator, with compulsory removal and future appointment bar
Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated
Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions
Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated
Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions
Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated
Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions
Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated
Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions
Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated
Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions
Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated
Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions
Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated
Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions
Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated
Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions
Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated
Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions
Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated
Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions
Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated
Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions
Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated
Sec. 2(a), new Environmental Research Act §1A · Government Power — Incorporates definitions of Gold Standard Science, scientific information, scientific misconduct and weight of scientific evidence from Executive Order 14303 of May 23, 2025; the bill does not reproduce those definitions
Sec. 2(e), new Environmental Research Act §6A · Government Power — Within 180 days of enactment EPA must establish scientific-integrity training for all EPA officers and employees on scientific research/publication, misconduct and executive-order-defined standards; no private-party sanction stated
Findings source: bill-scores-v2-batch49-findings-2026-11-15.md. Highlights come only from that file; no finding, score, or provision was invented for this page.
What you can do
Contact your U.S. Representative and Senators about this bill.
Find your Representative Contact your Senators
Spot an error on this page? Report it.