Be A Freedom Fighter · Bill Library

HR 10764 — Executive Settlement Review Act

Freedom score: 0 (scale −10 to +10)

Sponsor: Rep. Moore, Gwen [D-WI-4] · Latest action: Referred to the House Committee on the Judiciary. (2026-10-06)

Full text on GovInfo (introduced version) · Congress.gov · ← Bill Library index

Findings — 7 highlighted provisions

Each item below is one provision documented in the findings file. The same provision is highlighted in the full text underneath, with its section citation and criterion. Everything else on this page is plain, unreviewed bill text.

  1. Sec. 1 — Names the Executive Settlement Review Act See in text ↓
  2. Sec. 2, new 31 U.S.C. §1304(e)(1)–(3) · Privacy and Due Process — Bars a covered person from receiving a monetary settlement or award of $250,000 or more, or any nonmonetary relief, unless they comply with the new process. Requires claims for that relief to be brought before a three-judge D.C. district court panel, notwithstanding 28 U.S.C. §1491, and sends panel judgments to the D.C. Circuit rather than direct Supreme Court appeal under 28 U.S.C. §1253 See in text ↓
  3. Sec. 2, new §1304(e)(4)(A)–(H) · Privacy and Due Process — Includes the President and Vice President, cabinet, higher-paid Executive Office staff, political appointees, certain presidential special government employees, former appointees from the same presidency, close family of the President/Vice President/cabinet, and certain affiliated/controlled business entities. Not all federal employees are covered See in text ↓
  4. Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(1)–(3) · Government Power — Parties file settlement proposals in D.C. district court; the United States publishes them in the Federal Register and permits public comment. Written comments must be filed/published within 60 days. Relevant government-held settlement materials must generally be open to the public, except documents subject to federal privacy laws (e.g., Privacy Act/HIPAA), which must be filed under seal See in text ↓
  5. Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(4)(A)–(D) · Government Power — After the comment window, the panel considers comments; the United States responds publicly; parties submit detailed briefs, disputed/undisputed facts, evidence and communications. Shortening the normal 60-day window requires a court finding of extraordinary circumstances and no adverse public interest See in text ↓
  6. Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(5) · Government Power — Before approving a settlement, judges must find it not against the public interest and set aside proposals arbitrary/capricious, unconstitutional, ultra vires, procedurally unlawful, unsupported by the factual record, or unfair/collusive/excessive/unclear/unrelated to complaint claims See in text ↓
  7. Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(6)–(8) · Government Power — Permits testimony, experts, special masters, amicus participation and intervention, and review of comments. Requires disclosure to the court of parties’ communications. Stipulated facts may not be used as prima facie evidence or admitted without corroborating evidence in a different case. Drafting issue: paragraph (f)(6) refers to “paragraph (6)” when it apparently intends the review under paragraph (5); no assumed correction is scored See in text ↓

Full text (introduced version)

45 of 45 text blocks highlighted. Source: GovInfo, fetched cached.

[Congressional Bills 119th Congress] [From the U.S. Government Publishing Office] [H.R. 10764 Introduced in House (IH)] <DOC> 119th CONGRESS 2d Session H. R. 10764 To amend title 31, United States Code, to require certain procedures for compromise settlements or awards for executive branch officials, and for other purposes. _______________________________________________________________________ IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES October 6, 2026 Ms. Moore of Wisconsin introduced the following bill; which was referred to the Committee on the Judiciary _______________________________________________________________________ A BILL To amend title 31, United States Code, to require certain procedures for compromise settlements or awards for executive branch officials, and for other purposes. Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United States of America in Congress assembled,

SECTION 1. SHORT TITLE.

Sec. 1 — Names the Executive Settlement Review Act

This Act may be cited as the ``Executive Settlement Review Act''.

SEC. 2. RESTRICTION ON CERTAIN PAYMENTS FOR COMPROMISE SETTLEMENTS OR AWARDS.

Sec. 2, new 31 U.S.C. §1304(e)(1)–(3) · Privacy and Due Process — Bars a covered person from receiving a monetary settlement or award of $250,000 or more, or any nonmonetary relief, unless they comply with the new process. Requires claims for that relief to be brought before a three-judge D.C. district court panel, notwithstanding 28 U.S.C. §1491, and sends panel judgments to the D.C. Circuit rather than direct Supreme Court appeal under 28 U.S.C. §1253

Sec. 2, new §1304(e)(4)(A)–(H) · Privacy and Due Process — Includes the President and Vice President, cabinet, higher-paid Executive Office staff, political appointees, certain presidential special government employees, former appointees from the same presidency, close family of the President/Vice President/cabinet, and certain affiliated/controlled business entities. Not all federal employees are covered

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(1)–(3) · Government Power — Parties file settlement proposals in D.C. district court; the United States publishes them in the Federal Register and permits public comment. Written comments must be filed/published within 60 days. Relevant government-held settlement materials must generally be open to the public, except documents subject to federal privacy laws (e.g., Privacy Act/HIPAA), which must be filed under seal

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(4)(A)–(D) · Government Power — After the comment window, the panel considers comments; the United States responds publicly; parties submit detailed briefs, disputed/undisputed facts, evidence and communications. Shortening the normal 60-day window requires a court finding of extraordinary circumstances and no adverse public interest

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(5) · Government Power — Before approving a settlement, judges must find it not against the public interest and set aside proposals arbitrary/capricious, unconstitutional, ultra vires, procedurally unlawful, unsupported by the factual record, or unfair/collusive/excessive/unclear/unrelated to complaint claims

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(6)–(8) · Government Power — Permits testimony, experts, special masters, amicus participation and intervention, and review of comments. Requires disclosure to the court of parties’ communications. Stipulated facts may not be used as prima facie evidence or admitted without corroborating evidence in a different case. Drafting issue: paragraph (f)(6) refers to “paragraph (6)” when it apparently intends the review under paragraph (5); no assumed correction is scored

Section 1304 of title 31, United States Code, is amended by adding at the end the following: ``(e)(1) A compromise settlement or award for monetary relief in the amount of $250,000 or more, or nonmonetary relief, may not be awarded to a covered person, unless the covered person meets the requirements of this subsection and subsection (f).

Sec. 2, new 31 U.S.C. §1304(e)(1)–(3) · Privacy and Due Process — Bars a covered person from receiving a monetary settlement or award of $250,000 or more, or any nonmonetary relief, unless they comply with the new process. Requires claims for that relief to be brought before a three-judge D.C. district court panel, notwithstanding 28 U.S.C. §1491, and sends panel judgments to the D.C. Circuit rather than direct Supreme Court appeal under 28 U.S.C. §1253

Sec. 2, new §1304(e)(4)(A)–(H) · Privacy and Due Process — Includes the President and Vice President, cabinet, higher-paid Executive Office staff, political appointees, certain presidential special government employees, former appointees from the same presidency, close family of the President/Vice President/cabinet, and certain affiliated/controlled business entities. Not all federal employees are covered

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(1)–(3) · Government Power — Parties file settlement proposals in D.C. district court; the United States publishes them in the Federal Register and permits public comment. Written comments must be filed/published within 60 days. Relevant government-held settlement materials must generally be open to the public, except documents subject to federal privacy laws (e.g., Privacy Act/HIPAA), which must be filed under seal

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(4)(A)–(D) · Government Power — After the comment window, the panel considers comments; the United States responds publicly; parties submit detailed briefs, disputed/undisputed facts, evidence and communications. Shortening the normal 60-day window requires a court finding of extraordinary circumstances and no adverse public interest

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(5) · Government Power — Before approving a settlement, judges must find it not against the public interest and set aside proposals arbitrary/capricious, unconstitutional, ultra vires, procedurally unlawful, unsupported by the factual record, or unfair/collusive/excessive/unclear/unrelated to complaint claims

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(6)–(8) · Government Power — Permits testimony, experts, special masters, amicus participation and intervention, and review of comments. Requires disclosure to the court of parties’ communications. Stipulated facts may not be used as prima facie evidence or admitted without corroborating evidence in a different case. Drafting issue: paragraph (f)(6) refers to “paragraph (6)” when it apparently intends the review under paragraph (5); no assumed correction is scored

``(2) Notwithstanding section 1491 of title 28, a covered person seeking monetary relief in the amount of $250,000 or more, or nonmonetary relief, shall bring a suit for such relief against the United States, or against its agencies or officials upon obligations or liabilities of the United States, before a panel of 3 judges of the United States District Court for the District of Columbia, convened pursuant to section 2284 of title 28.

Sec. 2, new 31 U.S.C. §1304(e)(1)–(3) · Privacy and Due Process — Bars a covered person from receiving a monetary settlement or award of $250,000 or more, or any nonmonetary relief, unless they comply with the new process. Requires claims for that relief to be brought before a three-judge D.C. district court panel, notwithstanding 28 U.S.C. §1491, and sends panel judgments to the D.C. Circuit rather than direct Supreme Court appeal under 28 U.S.C. §1253

Sec. 2, new §1304(e)(4)(A)–(H) · Privacy and Due Process — Includes the President and Vice President, cabinet, higher-paid Executive Office staff, political appointees, certain presidential special government employees, former appointees from the same presidency, close family of the President/Vice President/cabinet, and certain affiliated/controlled business entities. Not all federal employees are covered

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(1)–(3) · Government Power — Parties file settlement proposals in D.C. district court; the United States publishes them in the Federal Register and permits public comment. Written comments must be filed/published within 60 days. Relevant government-held settlement materials must generally be open to the public, except documents subject to federal privacy laws (e.g., Privacy Act/HIPAA), which must be filed under seal

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(4)(A)–(D) · Government Power — After the comment window, the panel considers comments; the United States responds publicly; parties submit detailed briefs, disputed/undisputed facts, evidence and communications. Shortening the normal 60-day window requires a court finding of extraordinary circumstances and no adverse public interest

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(5) · Government Power — Before approving a settlement, judges must find it not against the public interest and set aside proposals arbitrary/capricious, unconstitutional, ultra vires, procedurally unlawful, unsupported by the factual record, or unfair/collusive/excessive/unclear/unrelated to complaint claims

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(6)–(8) · Government Power — Permits testimony, experts, special masters, amicus participation and intervention, and review of comments. Requires disclosure to the court of parties’ communications. Stipulated facts may not be used as prima facie evidence or admitted without corroborating evidence in a different case. Drafting issue: paragraph (f)(6) refers to “paragraph (6)” when it apparently intends the review under paragraph (5); no assumed correction is scored

``(3) Notwithstanding section 1253 of title 28, any appeal of a final judgment of the panel shall lie to the United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia.

Sec. 2, new 31 U.S.C. §1304(e)(1)–(3) · Privacy and Due Process — Bars a covered person from receiving a monetary settlement or award of $250,000 or more, or any nonmonetary relief, unless they comply with the new process. Requires claims for that relief to be brought before a three-judge D.C. district court panel, notwithstanding 28 U.S.C. §1491, and sends panel judgments to the D.C. Circuit rather than direct Supreme Court appeal under 28 U.S.C. §1253

Sec. 2, new §1304(e)(4)(A)–(H) · Privacy and Due Process — Includes the President and Vice President, cabinet, higher-paid Executive Office staff, political appointees, certain presidential special government employees, former appointees from the same presidency, close family of the President/Vice President/cabinet, and certain affiliated/controlled business entities. Not all federal employees are covered

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(1)–(3) · Government Power — Parties file settlement proposals in D.C. district court; the United States publishes them in the Federal Register and permits public comment. Written comments must be filed/published within 60 days. Relevant government-held settlement materials must generally be open to the public, except documents subject to federal privacy laws (e.g., Privacy Act/HIPAA), which must be filed under seal

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(4)(A)–(D) · Government Power — After the comment window, the panel considers comments; the United States responds publicly; parties submit detailed briefs, disputed/undisputed facts, evidence and communications. Shortening the normal 60-day window requires a court finding of extraordinary circumstances and no adverse public interest

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(5) · Government Power — Before approving a settlement, judges must find it not against the public interest and set aside proposals arbitrary/capricious, unconstitutional, ultra vires, procedurally unlawful, unsupported by the factual record, or unfair/collusive/excessive/unclear/unrelated to complaint claims

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(6)–(8) · Government Power — Permits testimony, experts, special masters, amicus participation and intervention, and review of comments. Requires disclosure to the court of parties’ communications. Stipulated facts may not be used as prima facie evidence or admitted without corroborating evidence in a different case. Drafting issue: paragraph (f)(6) refers to “paragraph (6)” when it apparently intends the review under paragraph (5); no assumed correction is scored

``(4) In this subsection, the term `covered person' means--

Sec. 2, new 31 U.S.C. §1304(e)(1)–(3) · Privacy and Due Process — Bars a covered person from receiving a monetary settlement or award of $250,000 or more, or any nonmonetary relief, unless they comply with the new process. Requires claims for that relief to be brought before a three-judge D.C. district court panel, notwithstanding 28 U.S.C. §1491, and sends panel judgments to the D.C. Circuit rather than direct Supreme Court appeal under 28 U.S.C. §1253

Sec. 2, new §1304(e)(4)(A)–(H) · Privacy and Due Process — Includes the President and Vice President, cabinet, higher-paid Executive Office staff, political appointees, certain presidential special government employees, former appointees from the same presidency, close family of the President/Vice President/cabinet, and certain affiliated/controlled business entities. Not all federal employees are covered

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(1)–(3) · Government Power — Parties file settlement proposals in D.C. district court; the United States publishes them in the Federal Register and permits public comment. Written comments must be filed/published within 60 days. Relevant government-held settlement materials must generally be open to the public, except documents subject to federal privacy laws (e.g., Privacy Act/HIPAA), which must be filed under seal

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(4)(A)–(D) · Government Power — After the comment window, the panel considers comments; the United States responds publicly; parties submit detailed briefs, disputed/undisputed facts, evidence and communications. Shortening the normal 60-day window requires a court finding of extraordinary circumstances and no adverse public interest

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(5) · Government Power — Before approving a settlement, judges must find it not against the public interest and set aside proposals arbitrary/capricious, unconstitutional, ultra vires, procedurally unlawful, unsupported by the factual record, or unfair/collusive/excessive/unclear/unrelated to complaint claims

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(6)–(8) · Government Power — Permits testimony, experts, special masters, amicus participation and intervention, and review of comments. Requires disclosure to the court of parties’ communications. Stipulated facts may not be used as prima facie evidence or admitted without corroborating evidence in a different case. Drafting issue: paragraph (f)(6) refers to “paragraph (6)” when it apparently intends the review under paragraph (5); no assumed correction is scored

``(A) the President or Vice President;

Sec. 2, new 31 U.S.C. §1304(e)(1)–(3) · Privacy and Due Process — Bars a covered person from receiving a monetary settlement or award of $250,000 or more, or any nonmonetary relief, unless they comply with the new process. Requires claims for that relief to be brought before a three-judge D.C. district court panel, notwithstanding 28 U.S.C. §1491, and sends panel judgments to the D.C. Circuit rather than direct Supreme Court appeal under 28 U.S.C. §1253

Sec. 2, new §1304(e)(4)(A)–(H) · Privacy and Due Process — Includes the President and Vice President, cabinet, higher-paid Executive Office staff, political appointees, certain presidential special government employees, former appointees from the same presidency, close family of the President/Vice President/cabinet, and certain affiliated/controlled business entities. Not all federal employees are covered

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(1)–(3) · Government Power — Parties file settlement proposals in D.C. district court; the United States publishes them in the Federal Register and permits public comment. Written comments must be filed/published within 60 days. Relevant government-held settlement materials must generally be open to the public, except documents subject to federal privacy laws (e.g., Privacy Act/HIPAA), which must be filed under seal

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(4)(A)–(D) · Government Power — After the comment window, the panel considers comments; the United States responds publicly; parties submit detailed briefs, disputed/undisputed facts, evidence and communications. Shortening the normal 60-day window requires a court finding of extraordinary circumstances and no adverse public interest

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(5) · Government Power — Before approving a settlement, judges must find it not against the public interest and set aside proposals arbitrary/capricious, unconstitutional, ultra vires, procedurally unlawful, unsupported by the factual record, or unfair/collusive/excessive/unclear/unrelated to complaint claims

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(6)–(8) · Government Power — Permits testimony, experts, special masters, amicus participation and intervention, and review of comments. Requires disclosure to the court of parties’ communications. Stipulated facts may not be used as prima facie evidence or admitted without corroborating evidence in a different case. Drafting issue: paragraph (f)(6) refers to “paragraph (6)” when it apparently intends the review under paragraph (5); no assumed correction is scored

``(B) any member of the cabinet;

Sec. 2, new 31 U.S.C. §1304(e)(1)–(3) · Privacy and Due Process — Bars a covered person from receiving a monetary settlement or award of $250,000 or more, or any nonmonetary relief, unless they comply with the new process. Requires claims for that relief to be brought before a three-judge D.C. district court panel, notwithstanding 28 U.S.C. §1491, and sends panel judgments to the D.C. Circuit rather than direct Supreme Court appeal under 28 U.S.C. §1253

Sec. 2, new §1304(e)(4)(A)–(H) · Privacy and Due Process — Includes the President and Vice President, cabinet, higher-paid Executive Office staff, political appointees, certain presidential special government employees, former appointees from the same presidency, close family of the President/Vice President/cabinet, and certain affiliated/controlled business entities. Not all federal employees are covered

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(1)–(3) · Government Power — Parties file settlement proposals in D.C. district court; the United States publishes them in the Federal Register and permits public comment. Written comments must be filed/published within 60 days. Relevant government-held settlement materials must generally be open to the public, except documents subject to federal privacy laws (e.g., Privacy Act/HIPAA), which must be filed under seal

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(4)(A)–(D) · Government Power — After the comment window, the panel considers comments; the United States responds publicly; parties submit detailed briefs, disputed/undisputed facts, evidence and communications. Shortening the normal 60-day window requires a court finding of extraordinary circumstances and no adverse public interest

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(5) · Government Power — Before approving a settlement, judges must find it not against the public interest and set aside proposals arbitrary/capricious, unconstitutional, ultra vires, procedurally unlawful, unsupported by the factual record, or unfair/collusive/excessive/unclear/unrelated to complaint claims

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(6)–(8) · Government Power — Permits testimony, experts, special masters, amicus participation and intervention, and review of comments. Requires disclosure to the court of parties’ communications. Stipulated facts may not be used as prima facie evidence or admitted without corroborating evidence in a different case. Drafting issue: paragraph (f)(6) refers to “paragraph (6)” when it apparently intends the review under paragraph (5); no assumed correction is scored

``(C) any individual who is employed by the Executive Office of the President who is paid at a rate of basic pay equivalent to or exceeding the GS-15 level;

Sec. 2, new 31 U.S.C. §1304(e)(1)–(3) · Privacy and Due Process — Bars a covered person from receiving a monetary settlement or award of $250,000 or more, or any nonmonetary relief, unless they comply with the new process. Requires claims for that relief to be brought before a three-judge D.C. district court panel, notwithstanding 28 U.S.C. §1491, and sends panel judgments to the D.C. Circuit rather than direct Supreme Court appeal under 28 U.S.C. §1253

Sec. 2, new §1304(e)(4)(A)–(H) · Privacy and Due Process — Includes the President and Vice President, cabinet, higher-paid Executive Office staff, political appointees, certain presidential special government employees, former appointees from the same presidency, close family of the President/Vice President/cabinet, and certain affiliated/controlled business entities. Not all federal employees are covered

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(1)–(3) · Government Power — Parties file settlement proposals in D.C. district court; the United States publishes them in the Federal Register and permits public comment. Written comments must be filed/published within 60 days. Relevant government-held settlement materials must generally be open to the public, except documents subject to federal privacy laws (e.g., Privacy Act/HIPAA), which must be filed under seal

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(4)(A)–(D) · Government Power — After the comment window, the panel considers comments; the United States responds publicly; parties submit detailed briefs, disputed/undisputed facts, evidence and communications. Shortening the normal 60-day window requires a court finding of extraordinary circumstances and no adverse public interest

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(5) · Government Power — Before approving a settlement, judges must find it not against the public interest and set aside proposals arbitrary/capricious, unconstitutional, ultra vires, procedurally unlawful, unsupported by the factual record, or unfair/collusive/excessive/unclear/unrelated to complaint claims

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(6)–(8) · Government Power — Permits testimony, experts, special masters, amicus participation and intervention, and review of comments. Requires disclosure to the court of parties’ communications. Stipulated facts may not be used as prima facie evidence or admitted without corroborating evidence in a different case. Drafting issue: paragraph (f)(6) refers to “paragraph (6)” when it apparently intends the review under paragraph (5); no assumed correction is scored

``(D) a political appointee of the President;

Sec. 2, new 31 U.S.C. §1304(e)(1)–(3) · Privacy and Due Process — Bars a covered person from receiving a monetary settlement or award of $250,000 or more, or any nonmonetary relief, unless they comply with the new process. Requires claims for that relief to be brought before a three-judge D.C. district court panel, notwithstanding 28 U.S.C. §1491, and sends panel judgments to the D.C. Circuit rather than direct Supreme Court appeal under 28 U.S.C. §1253

Sec. 2, new §1304(e)(4)(A)–(H) · Privacy and Due Process — Includes the President and Vice President, cabinet, higher-paid Executive Office staff, political appointees, certain presidential special government employees, former appointees from the same presidency, close family of the President/Vice President/cabinet, and certain affiliated/controlled business entities. Not all federal employees are covered

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(1)–(3) · Government Power — Parties file settlement proposals in D.C. district court; the United States publishes them in the Federal Register and permits public comment. Written comments must be filed/published within 60 days. Relevant government-held settlement materials must generally be open to the public, except documents subject to federal privacy laws (e.g., Privacy Act/HIPAA), which must be filed under seal

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(4)(A)–(D) · Government Power — After the comment window, the panel considers comments; the United States responds publicly; parties submit detailed briefs, disputed/undisputed facts, evidence and communications. Shortening the normal 60-day window requires a court finding of extraordinary circumstances and no adverse public interest

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(5) · Government Power — Before approving a settlement, judges must find it not against the public interest and set aside proposals arbitrary/capricious, unconstitutional, ultra vires, procedurally unlawful, unsupported by the factual record, or unfair/collusive/excessive/unclear/unrelated to complaint claims

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(6)–(8) · Government Power — Permits testimony, experts, special masters, amicus participation and intervention, and review of comments. Requires disclosure to the court of parties’ communications. Stipulated facts may not be used as prima facie evidence or admitted without corroborating evidence in a different case. Drafting issue: paragraph (f)(6) refers to “paragraph (6)” when it apparently intends the review under paragraph (5); no assumed correction is scored

``(E) a special government employee (as defined in section 202 of title 18) within the executive branch who is retained, designated, appointed, or employed by the President;

Sec. 2, new 31 U.S.C. §1304(e)(1)–(3) · Privacy and Due Process — Bars a covered person from receiving a monetary settlement or award of $250,000 or more, or any nonmonetary relief, unless they comply with the new process. Requires claims for that relief to be brought before a three-judge D.C. district court panel, notwithstanding 28 U.S.C. §1491, and sends panel judgments to the D.C. Circuit rather than direct Supreme Court appeal under 28 U.S.C. §1253

Sec. 2, new §1304(e)(4)(A)–(H) · Privacy and Due Process — Includes the President and Vice President, cabinet, higher-paid Executive Office staff, political appointees, certain presidential special government employees, former appointees from the same presidency, close family of the President/Vice President/cabinet, and certain affiliated/controlled business entities. Not all federal employees are covered

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(1)–(3) · Government Power — Parties file settlement proposals in D.C. district court; the United States publishes them in the Federal Register and permits public comment. Written comments must be filed/published within 60 days. Relevant government-held settlement materials must generally be open to the public, except documents subject to federal privacy laws (e.g., Privacy Act/HIPAA), which must be filed under seal

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(4)(A)–(D) · Government Power — After the comment window, the panel considers comments; the United States responds publicly; parties submit detailed briefs, disputed/undisputed facts, evidence and communications. Shortening the normal 60-day window requires a court finding of extraordinary circumstances and no adverse public interest

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(5) · Government Power — Before approving a settlement, judges must find it not against the public interest and set aside proposals arbitrary/capricious, unconstitutional, ultra vires, procedurally unlawful, unsupported by the factual record, or unfair/collusive/excessive/unclear/unrelated to complaint claims

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(6)–(8) · Government Power — Permits testimony, experts, special masters, amicus participation and intervention, and review of comments. Requires disclosure to the court of parties’ communications. Stipulated facts may not be used as prima facie evidence or admitted without corroborating evidence in a different case. Drafting issue: paragraph (f)(6) refers to “paragraph (6)” when it apparently intends the review under paragraph (5); no assumed correction is scored

``(F) an individual who served in a position described under subparagraph (B), (C), (D), or (E) during the period for which the President who appointed such individual is in Office, including any period after such individual leaves such a position;

Sec. 2, new 31 U.S.C. §1304(e)(1)–(3) · Privacy and Due Process — Bars a covered person from receiving a monetary settlement or award of $250,000 or more, or any nonmonetary relief, unless they comply with the new process. Requires claims for that relief to be brought before a three-judge D.C. district court panel, notwithstanding 28 U.S.C. §1491, and sends panel judgments to the D.C. Circuit rather than direct Supreme Court appeal under 28 U.S.C. §1253

Sec. 2, new §1304(e)(4)(A)–(H) · Privacy and Due Process — Includes the President and Vice President, cabinet, higher-paid Executive Office staff, political appointees, certain presidential special government employees, former appointees from the same presidency, close family of the President/Vice President/cabinet, and certain affiliated/controlled business entities. Not all federal employees are covered

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(1)–(3) · Government Power — Parties file settlement proposals in D.C. district court; the United States publishes them in the Federal Register and permits public comment. Written comments must be filed/published within 60 days. Relevant government-held settlement materials must generally be open to the public, except documents subject to federal privacy laws (e.g., Privacy Act/HIPAA), which must be filed under seal

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(4)(A)–(D) · Government Power — After the comment window, the panel considers comments; the United States responds publicly; parties submit detailed briefs, disputed/undisputed facts, evidence and communications. Shortening the normal 60-day window requires a court finding of extraordinary circumstances and no adverse public interest

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(5) · Government Power — Before approving a settlement, judges must find it not against the public interest and set aside proposals arbitrary/capricious, unconstitutional, ultra vires, procedurally unlawful, unsupported by the factual record, or unfair/collusive/excessive/unclear/unrelated to complaint claims

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(6)–(8) · Government Power — Permits testimony, experts, special masters, amicus participation and intervention, and review of comments. Requires disclosure to the court of parties’ communications. Stipulated facts may not be used as prima facie evidence or admitted without corroborating evidence in a different case. Drafting issue: paragraph (f)(6) refers to “paragraph (6)” when it apparently intends the review under paragraph (5); no assumed correction is scored

``(G) the parent, spouse, child, or spouse of a child of an individual described in subparagraph (A) or (B); and

Sec. 2, new 31 U.S.C. §1304(e)(1)–(3) · Privacy and Due Process — Bars a covered person from receiving a monetary settlement or award of $250,000 or more, or any nonmonetary relief, unless they comply with the new process. Requires claims for that relief to be brought before a three-judge D.C. district court panel, notwithstanding 28 U.S.C. §1491, and sends panel judgments to the D.C. Circuit rather than direct Supreme Court appeal under 28 U.S.C. §1253

Sec. 2, new §1304(e)(4)(A)–(H) · Privacy and Due Process — Includes the President and Vice President, cabinet, higher-paid Executive Office staff, political appointees, certain presidential special government employees, former appointees from the same presidency, close family of the President/Vice President/cabinet, and certain affiliated/controlled business entities. Not all federal employees are covered

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(1)–(3) · Government Power — Parties file settlement proposals in D.C. district court; the United States publishes them in the Federal Register and permits public comment. Written comments must be filed/published within 60 days. Relevant government-held settlement materials must generally be open to the public, except documents subject to federal privacy laws (e.g., Privacy Act/HIPAA), which must be filed under seal

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(4)(A)–(D) · Government Power — After the comment window, the panel considers comments; the United States responds publicly; parties submit detailed briefs, disputed/undisputed facts, evidence and communications. Shortening the normal 60-day window requires a court finding of extraordinary circumstances and no adverse public interest

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(5) · Government Power — Before approving a settlement, judges must find it not against the public interest and set aside proposals arbitrary/capricious, unconstitutional, ultra vires, procedurally unlawful, unsupported by the factual record, or unfair/collusive/excessive/unclear/unrelated to complaint claims

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(6)–(8) · Government Power — Permits testimony, experts, special masters, amicus participation and intervention, and review of comments. Requires disclosure to the court of parties’ communications. Stipulated facts may not be used as prima facie evidence or admitted without corroborating evidence in a different case. Drafting issue: paragraph (f)(6) refers to “paragraph (6)” when it apparently intends the review under paragraph (5); no assumed correction is scored

``(H) an entity-- ``(i) affiliated with any individual described in subparagraphs (A) through (G), except that the entity's employment of such individual in a non-officer position is not an affiliation for the purpose of this subsection; ``(ii) in which any of such individuals possess any ownership interest, or authority to control or influence decisions; or ``(iii) which is otherwise subject to the power of such individuals to determine, direct, or decide important matters affecting said entity. ``(f)(1) Any proposal for a compromise settlement or award agreed to by each party to a suit brought under subsection (e)(2) shall be--

Sec. 2, new 31 U.S.C. §1304(e)(1)–(3) · Privacy and Due Process — Bars a covered person from receiving a monetary settlement or award of $250,000 or more, or any nonmonetary relief, unless they comply with the new process. Requires claims for that relief to be brought before a three-judge D.C. district court panel, notwithstanding 28 U.S.C. §1491, and sends panel judgments to the D.C. Circuit rather than direct Supreme Court appeal under 28 U.S.C. §1253

Sec. 2, new §1304(e)(4)(A)–(H) · Privacy and Due Process — Includes the President and Vice President, cabinet, higher-paid Executive Office staff, political appointees, certain presidential special government employees, former appointees from the same presidency, close family of the President/Vice President/cabinet, and certain affiliated/controlled business entities. Not all federal employees are covered

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(1)–(3) · Government Power — Parties file settlement proposals in D.C. district court; the United States publishes them in the Federal Register and permits public comment. Written comments must be filed/published within 60 days. Relevant government-held settlement materials must generally be open to the public, except documents subject to federal privacy laws (e.g., Privacy Act/HIPAA), which must be filed under seal

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(4)(A)–(D) · Government Power — After the comment window, the panel considers comments; the United States responds publicly; parties submit detailed briefs, disputed/undisputed facts, evidence and communications. Shortening the normal 60-day window requires a court finding of extraordinary circumstances and no adverse public interest

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(5) · Government Power — Before approving a settlement, judges must find it not against the public interest and set aside proposals arbitrary/capricious, unconstitutional, ultra vires, procedurally unlawful, unsupported by the factual record, or unfair/collusive/excessive/unclear/unrelated to complaint claims

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(6)–(8) · Government Power — Permits testimony, experts, special masters, amicus participation and intervention, and review of comments. Requires disclosure to the court of parties’ communications. Stipulated facts may not be used as prima facie evidence or admitted without corroborating evidence in a different case. Drafting issue: paragraph (f)(6) refers to “paragraph (6)” when it apparently intends the review under paragraph (5); no assumed correction is scored

``(A) filed with the United States District Court for the District of Columbia panel convened pursuant to section 2284 of title 28;

Sec. 2, new 31 U.S.C. §1304(e)(1)–(3) · Privacy and Due Process — Bars a covered person from receiving a monetary settlement or award of $250,000 or more, or any nonmonetary relief, unless they comply with the new process. Requires claims for that relief to be brought before a three-judge D.C. district court panel, notwithstanding 28 U.S.C. §1491, and sends panel judgments to the D.C. Circuit rather than direct Supreme Court appeal under 28 U.S.C. §1253

Sec. 2, new §1304(e)(4)(A)–(H) · Privacy and Due Process — Includes the President and Vice President, cabinet, higher-paid Executive Office staff, political appointees, certain presidential special government employees, former appointees from the same presidency, close family of the President/Vice President/cabinet, and certain affiliated/controlled business entities. Not all federal employees are covered

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(1)–(3) · Government Power — Parties file settlement proposals in D.C. district court; the United States publishes them in the Federal Register and permits public comment. Written comments must be filed/published within 60 days. Relevant government-held settlement materials must generally be open to the public, except documents subject to federal privacy laws (e.g., Privacy Act/HIPAA), which must be filed under seal

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(4)(A)–(D) · Government Power — After the comment window, the panel considers comments; the United States responds publicly; parties submit detailed briefs, disputed/undisputed facts, evidence and communications. Shortening the normal 60-day window requires a court finding of extraordinary circumstances and no adverse public interest

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(5) · Government Power — Before approving a settlement, judges must find it not against the public interest and set aside proposals arbitrary/capricious, unconstitutional, ultra vires, procedurally unlawful, unsupported by the factual record, or unfair/collusive/excessive/unclear/unrelated to complaint claims

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(6)–(8) · Government Power — Permits testimony, experts, special masters, amicus participation and intervention, and review of comments. Requires disclosure to the court of parties’ communications. Stipulated facts may not be used as prima facie evidence or admitted without corroborating evidence in a different case. Drafting issue: paragraph (f)(6) refers to “paragraph (6)” when it apparently intends the review under paragraph (5); no assumed correction is scored

``(B) published in the Federal Register by the United States; and

Sec. 2, new 31 U.S.C. §1304(e)(1)–(3) · Privacy and Due Process — Bars a covered person from receiving a monetary settlement or award of $250,000 or more, or any nonmonetary relief, unless they comply with the new process. Requires claims for that relief to be brought before a three-judge D.C. district court panel, notwithstanding 28 U.S.C. §1491, and sends panel judgments to the D.C. Circuit rather than direct Supreme Court appeal under 28 U.S.C. §1253

Sec. 2, new §1304(e)(4)(A)–(H) · Privacy and Due Process — Includes the President and Vice President, cabinet, higher-paid Executive Office staff, political appointees, certain presidential special government employees, former appointees from the same presidency, close family of the President/Vice President/cabinet, and certain affiliated/controlled business entities. Not all federal employees are covered

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(1)–(3) · Government Power — Parties file settlement proposals in D.C. district court; the United States publishes them in the Federal Register and permits public comment. Written comments must be filed/published within 60 days. Relevant government-held settlement materials must generally be open to the public, except documents subject to federal privacy laws (e.g., Privacy Act/HIPAA), which must be filed under seal

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(4)(A)–(D) · Government Power — After the comment window, the panel considers comments; the United States responds publicly; parties submit detailed briefs, disputed/undisputed facts, evidence and communications. Shortening the normal 60-day window requires a court finding of extraordinary circumstances and no adverse public interest

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(5) · Government Power — Before approving a settlement, judges must find it not against the public interest and set aside proposals arbitrary/capricious, unconstitutional, ultra vires, procedurally unlawful, unsupported by the factual record, or unfair/collusive/excessive/unclear/unrelated to complaint claims

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(6)–(8) · Government Power — Permits testimony, experts, special masters, amicus participation and intervention, and review of comments. Requires disclosure to the court of parties’ communications. Stipulated facts may not be used as prima facie evidence or admitted without corroborating evidence in a different case. Drafting issue: paragraph (f)(6) refers to “paragraph (6)” when it apparently intends the review under paragraph (5); no assumed correction is scored

``(C) made available for public comment.

Sec. 2, new 31 U.S.C. §1304(e)(1)–(3) · Privacy and Due Process — Bars a covered person from receiving a monetary settlement or award of $250,000 or more, or any nonmonetary relief, unless they comply with the new process. Requires claims for that relief to be brought before a three-judge D.C. district court panel, notwithstanding 28 U.S.C. §1491, and sends panel judgments to the D.C. Circuit rather than direct Supreme Court appeal under 28 U.S.C. §1253

Sec. 2, new §1304(e)(4)(A)–(H) · Privacy and Due Process — Includes the President and Vice President, cabinet, higher-paid Executive Office staff, political appointees, certain presidential special government employees, former appointees from the same presidency, close family of the President/Vice President/cabinet, and certain affiliated/controlled business entities. Not all federal employees are covered

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(1)–(3) · Government Power — Parties file settlement proposals in D.C. district court; the United States publishes them in the Federal Register and permits public comment. Written comments must be filed/published within 60 days. Relevant government-held settlement materials must generally be open to the public, except documents subject to federal privacy laws (e.g., Privacy Act/HIPAA), which must be filed under seal

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(4)(A)–(D) · Government Power — After the comment window, the panel considers comments; the United States responds publicly; parties submit detailed briefs, disputed/undisputed facts, evidence and communications. Shortening the normal 60-day window requires a court finding of extraordinary circumstances and no adverse public interest

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(5) · Government Power — Before approving a settlement, judges must find it not against the public interest and set aside proposals arbitrary/capricious, unconstitutional, ultra vires, procedurally unlawful, unsupported by the factual record, or unfair/collusive/excessive/unclear/unrelated to complaint claims

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(6)–(8) · Government Power — Permits testimony, experts, special masters, amicus participation and intervention, and review of comments. Requires disclosure to the court of parties’ communications. Stipulated facts may not be used as prima facie evidence or admitted without corroborating evidence in a different case. Drafting issue: paragraph (f)(6) refers to “paragraph (6)” when it apparently intends the review under paragraph (5); no assumed correction is scored

``(2) Any written public comment relating to such proposal, shall be filed with such district court panel and published by the United States in the Federal Register not later than 60 days after the filing of such proposal with the district court panel. ``(3)(A) Except as provided in subparagraph (B), copies of such proposal and any other materials and documents which the United States considered determinative in formulating such proposal, shall also be made available to the public at the district court and in such other districts as the court may subsequently direct.

Sec. 2, new 31 U.S.C. §1304(e)(1)–(3) · Privacy and Due Process — Bars a covered person from receiving a monetary settlement or award of $250,000 or more, or any nonmonetary relief, unless they comply with the new process. Requires claims for that relief to be brought before a three-judge D.C. district court panel, notwithstanding 28 U.S.C. §1491, and sends panel judgments to the D.C. Circuit rather than direct Supreme Court appeal under 28 U.S.C. §1253

Sec. 2, new §1304(e)(4)(A)–(H) · Privacy and Due Process — Includes the President and Vice President, cabinet, higher-paid Executive Office staff, political appointees, certain presidential special government employees, former appointees from the same presidency, close family of the President/Vice President/cabinet, and certain affiliated/controlled business entities. Not all federal employees are covered

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(1)–(3) · Government Power — Parties file settlement proposals in D.C. district court; the United States publishes them in the Federal Register and permits public comment. Written comments must be filed/published within 60 days. Relevant government-held settlement materials must generally be open to the public, except documents subject to federal privacy laws (e.g., Privacy Act/HIPAA), which must be filed under seal

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(4)(A)–(D) · Government Power — After the comment window, the panel considers comments; the United States responds publicly; parties submit detailed briefs, disputed/undisputed facts, evidence and communications. Shortening the normal 60-day window requires a court finding of extraordinary circumstances and no adverse public interest

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(5) · Government Power — Before approving a settlement, judges must find it not against the public interest and set aside proposals arbitrary/capricious, unconstitutional, ultra vires, procedurally unlawful, unsupported by the factual record, or unfair/collusive/excessive/unclear/unrelated to complaint claims

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(6)–(8) · Government Power — Permits testimony, experts, special masters, amicus participation and intervention, and review of comments. Requires disclosure to the court of parties’ communications. Stipulated facts may not be used as prima facie evidence or admitted without corroborating evidence in a different case. Drafting issue: paragraph (f)(6) refers to “paragraph (6)” when it apparently intends the review under paragraph (5); no assumed correction is scored

``(B) Subparagraph (A) shall not apply to any document that is subject to Federal privacy laws, including the Privacy Act of 1974 or the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act and such documents shall be filed under seal with the court. ``(4)(A) After the 60-day period described in paragraph (2), and such additional time as the United States may request and the court may grant to respond to such public comments, the district court panel shall consider any written comments and responses relating to the proposal submitted under paragraph (1).

Sec. 2, new 31 U.S.C. §1304(e)(1)–(3) · Privacy and Due Process — Bars a covered person from receiving a monetary settlement or award of $250,000 or more, or any nonmonetary relief, unless they comply with the new process. Requires claims for that relief to be brought before a three-judge D.C. district court panel, notwithstanding 28 U.S.C. §1491, and sends panel judgments to the D.C. Circuit rather than direct Supreme Court appeal under 28 U.S.C. §1253

Sec. 2, new §1304(e)(4)(A)–(H) · Privacy and Due Process — Includes the President and Vice President, cabinet, higher-paid Executive Office staff, political appointees, certain presidential special government employees, former appointees from the same presidency, close family of the President/Vice President/cabinet, and certain affiliated/controlled business entities. Not all federal employees are covered

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(1)–(3) · Government Power — Parties file settlement proposals in D.C. district court; the United States publishes them in the Federal Register and permits public comment. Written comments must be filed/published within 60 days. Relevant government-held settlement materials must generally be open to the public, except documents subject to federal privacy laws (e.g., Privacy Act/HIPAA), which must be filed under seal

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(4)(A)–(D) · Government Power — After the comment window, the panel considers comments; the United States responds publicly; parties submit detailed briefs, disputed/undisputed facts, evidence and communications. Shortening the normal 60-day window requires a court finding of extraordinary circumstances and no adverse public interest

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(5) · Government Power — Before approving a settlement, judges must find it not against the public interest and set aside proposals arbitrary/capricious, unconstitutional, ultra vires, procedurally unlawful, unsupported by the factual record, or unfair/collusive/excessive/unclear/unrelated to complaint claims

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(6)–(8) · Government Power — Permits testimony, experts, special masters, amicus participation and intervention, and review of comments. Requires disclosure to the court of parties’ communications. Stipulated facts may not be used as prima facie evidence or admitted without corroborating evidence in a different case. Drafting issue: paragraph (f)(6) refers to “paragraph (6)” when it apparently intends the review under paragraph (5); no assumed correction is scored

``(B) At the close of the period during which such public comments may be received, the United States shall file with the district court and cause to be published in the Federal Register a response to such public comments during the additional time period granted under subparagraph (A).

Sec. 2, new 31 U.S.C. §1304(e)(1)–(3) · Privacy and Due Process — Bars a covered person from receiving a monetary settlement or award of $250,000 or more, or any nonmonetary relief, unless they comply with the new process. Requires claims for that relief to be brought before a three-judge D.C. district court panel, notwithstanding 28 U.S.C. §1491, and sends panel judgments to the D.C. Circuit rather than direct Supreme Court appeal under 28 U.S.C. §1253

Sec. 2, new §1304(e)(4)(A)–(H) · Privacy and Due Process — Includes the President and Vice President, cabinet, higher-paid Executive Office staff, political appointees, certain presidential special government employees, former appointees from the same presidency, close family of the President/Vice President/cabinet, and certain affiliated/controlled business entities. Not all federal employees are covered

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(1)–(3) · Government Power — Parties file settlement proposals in D.C. district court; the United States publishes them in the Federal Register and permits public comment. Written comments must be filed/published within 60 days. Relevant government-held settlement materials must generally be open to the public, except documents subject to federal privacy laws (e.g., Privacy Act/HIPAA), which must be filed under seal

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(4)(A)–(D) · Government Power — After the comment window, the panel considers comments; the United States responds publicly; parties submit detailed briefs, disputed/undisputed facts, evidence and communications. Shortening the normal 60-day window requires a court finding of extraordinary circumstances and no adverse public interest

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(5) · Government Power — Before approving a settlement, judges must find it not against the public interest and set aside proposals arbitrary/capricious, unconstitutional, ultra vires, procedurally unlawful, unsupported by the factual record, or unfair/collusive/excessive/unclear/unrelated to complaint claims

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(6)–(8) · Government Power — Permits testimony, experts, special masters, amicus participation and intervention, and review of comments. Requires disclosure to the court of parties’ communications. Stipulated facts may not be used as prima facie evidence or admitted without corroborating evidence in a different case. Drafting issue: paragraph (f)(6) refers to “paragraph (6)” when it apparently intends the review under paragraph (5); no assumed correction is scored

``(C) At the expiration of the period for public comment and response, each party to the suit shall file with the district court a brief that explains the case or controversy, the reason the party agreed to the settlement, and the reason the settlement should be approved by the court. Such brief shall include--

Sec. 2, new 31 U.S.C. §1304(e)(1)–(3) · Privacy and Due Process — Bars a covered person from receiving a monetary settlement or award of $250,000 or more, or any nonmonetary relief, unless they comply with the new process. Requires claims for that relief to be brought before a three-judge D.C. district court panel, notwithstanding 28 U.S.C. §1491, and sends panel judgments to the D.C. Circuit rather than direct Supreme Court appeal under 28 U.S.C. §1253

Sec. 2, new §1304(e)(4)(A)–(H) · Privacy and Due Process — Includes the President and Vice President, cabinet, higher-paid Executive Office staff, political appointees, certain presidential special government employees, former appointees from the same presidency, close family of the President/Vice President/cabinet, and certain affiliated/controlled business entities. Not all federal employees are covered

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(1)–(3) · Government Power — Parties file settlement proposals in D.C. district court; the United States publishes them in the Federal Register and permits public comment. Written comments must be filed/published within 60 days. Relevant government-held settlement materials must generally be open to the public, except documents subject to federal privacy laws (e.g., Privacy Act/HIPAA), which must be filed under seal

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(4)(A)–(D) · Government Power — After the comment window, the panel considers comments; the United States responds publicly; parties submit detailed briefs, disputed/undisputed facts, evidence and communications. Shortening the normal 60-day window requires a court finding of extraordinary circumstances and no adverse public interest

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(5) · Government Power — Before approving a settlement, judges must find it not against the public interest and set aside proposals arbitrary/capricious, unconstitutional, ultra vires, procedurally unlawful, unsupported by the factual record, or unfair/collusive/excessive/unclear/unrelated to complaint claims

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(6)–(8) · Government Power — Permits testimony, experts, special masters, amicus participation and intervention, and review of comments. Requires disclosure to the court of parties’ communications. Stipulated facts may not be used as prima facie evidence or admitted without corroborating evidence in a different case. Drafting issue: paragraph (f)(6) refers to “paragraph (6)” when it apparently intends the review under paragraph (5); no assumed correction is scored

``(i) a statement of disputed and undisputed facts;

Sec. 2, new 31 U.S.C. §1304(e)(1)–(3) · Privacy and Due Process — Bars a covered person from receiving a monetary settlement or award of $250,000 or more, or any nonmonetary relief, unless they comply with the new process. Requires claims for that relief to be brought before a three-judge D.C. district court panel, notwithstanding 28 U.S.C. §1491, and sends panel judgments to the D.C. Circuit rather than direct Supreme Court appeal under 28 U.S.C. §1253

Sec. 2, new §1304(e)(4)(A)–(H) · Privacy and Due Process — Includes the President and Vice President, cabinet, higher-paid Executive Office staff, political appointees, certain presidential special government employees, former appointees from the same presidency, close family of the President/Vice President/cabinet, and certain affiliated/controlled business entities. Not all federal employees are covered

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(1)–(3) · Government Power — Parties file settlement proposals in D.C. district court; the United States publishes them in the Federal Register and permits public comment. Written comments must be filed/published within 60 days. Relevant government-held settlement materials must generally be open to the public, except documents subject to federal privacy laws (e.g., Privacy Act/HIPAA), which must be filed under seal

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(4)(A)–(D) · Government Power — After the comment window, the panel considers comments; the United States responds publicly; parties submit detailed briefs, disputed/undisputed facts, evidence and communications. Shortening the normal 60-day window requires a court finding of extraordinary circumstances and no adverse public interest

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(5) · Government Power — Before approving a settlement, judges must find it not against the public interest and set aside proposals arbitrary/capricious, unconstitutional, ultra vires, procedurally unlawful, unsupported by the factual record, or unfair/collusive/excessive/unclear/unrelated to complaint claims

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(6)–(8) · Government Power — Permits testimony, experts, special masters, amicus participation and intervention, and review of comments. Requires disclosure to the court of parties’ communications. Stipulated facts may not be used as prima facie evidence or admitted without corroborating evidence in a different case. Drafting issue: paragraph (f)(6) refers to “paragraph (6)” when it apparently intends the review under paragraph (5); no assumed correction is scored

``(ii) an evidentiary record, including any documents which were determinative in formulating the proposed settlement;

Sec. 2, new 31 U.S.C. §1304(e)(1)–(3) · Privacy and Due Process — Bars a covered person from receiving a monetary settlement or award of $250,000 or more, or any nonmonetary relief, unless they comply with the new process. Requires claims for that relief to be brought before a three-judge D.C. district court panel, notwithstanding 28 U.S.C. §1491, and sends panel judgments to the D.C. Circuit rather than direct Supreme Court appeal under 28 U.S.C. §1253

Sec. 2, new §1304(e)(4)(A)–(H) · Privacy and Due Process — Includes the President and Vice President, cabinet, higher-paid Executive Office staff, political appointees, certain presidential special government employees, former appointees from the same presidency, close family of the President/Vice President/cabinet, and certain affiliated/controlled business entities. Not all federal employees are covered

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(1)–(3) · Government Power — Parties file settlement proposals in D.C. district court; the United States publishes them in the Federal Register and permits public comment. Written comments must be filed/published within 60 days. Relevant government-held settlement materials must generally be open to the public, except documents subject to federal privacy laws (e.g., Privacy Act/HIPAA), which must be filed under seal

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(4)(A)–(D) · Government Power — After the comment window, the panel considers comments; the United States responds publicly; parties submit detailed briefs, disputed/undisputed facts, evidence and communications. Shortening the normal 60-day window requires a court finding of extraordinary circumstances and no adverse public interest

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(5) · Government Power — Before approving a settlement, judges must find it not against the public interest and set aside proposals arbitrary/capricious, unconstitutional, ultra vires, procedurally unlawful, unsupported by the factual record, or unfair/collusive/excessive/unclear/unrelated to complaint claims

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(6)–(8) · Government Power — Permits testimony, experts, special masters, amicus participation and intervention, and review of comments. Requires disclosure to the court of parties’ communications. Stipulated facts may not be used as prima facie evidence or admitted without corroborating evidence in a different case. Drafting issue: paragraph (f)(6) refers to “paragraph (6)” when it apparently intends the review under paragraph (5); no assumed correction is scored

``(iii) a description of the adversity underlying the suit and details of any and all communications between the parties; and

Sec. 2, new 31 U.S.C. §1304(e)(1)–(3) · Privacy and Due Process — Bars a covered person from receiving a monetary settlement or award of $250,000 or more, or any nonmonetary relief, unless they comply with the new process. Requires claims for that relief to be brought before a three-judge D.C. district court panel, notwithstanding 28 U.S.C. §1491, and sends panel judgments to the D.C. Circuit rather than direct Supreme Court appeal under 28 U.S.C. §1253

Sec. 2, new §1304(e)(4)(A)–(H) · Privacy and Due Process — Includes the President and Vice President, cabinet, higher-paid Executive Office staff, political appointees, certain presidential special government employees, former appointees from the same presidency, close family of the President/Vice President/cabinet, and certain affiliated/controlled business entities. Not all federal employees are covered

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(1)–(3) · Government Power — Parties file settlement proposals in D.C. district court; the United States publishes them in the Federal Register and permits public comment. Written comments must be filed/published within 60 days. Relevant government-held settlement materials must generally be open to the public, except documents subject to federal privacy laws (e.g., Privacy Act/HIPAA), which must be filed under seal

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(4)(A)–(D) · Government Power — After the comment window, the panel considers comments; the United States responds publicly; parties submit detailed briefs, disputed/undisputed facts, evidence and communications. Shortening the normal 60-day window requires a court finding of extraordinary circumstances and no adverse public interest

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(5) · Government Power — Before approving a settlement, judges must find it not against the public interest and set aside proposals arbitrary/capricious, unconstitutional, ultra vires, procedurally unlawful, unsupported by the factual record, or unfair/collusive/excessive/unclear/unrelated to complaint claims

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(6)–(8) · Government Power — Permits testimony, experts, special masters, amicus participation and intervention, and review of comments. Requires disclosure to the court of parties’ communications. Stipulated facts may not be used as prima facie evidence or admitted without corroborating evidence in a different case. Drafting issue: paragraph (f)(6) refers to “paragraph (6)” when it apparently intends the review under paragraph (5); no assumed correction is scored

``(iv) a summary of public comments, and, in the brief filed by the United States, the response of the United States to such comments.

Sec. 2, new 31 U.S.C. §1304(e)(1)–(3) · Privacy and Due Process — Bars a covered person from receiving a monetary settlement or award of $250,000 or more, or any nonmonetary relief, unless they comply with the new process. Requires claims for that relief to be brought before a three-judge D.C. district court panel, notwithstanding 28 U.S.C. §1491, and sends panel judgments to the D.C. Circuit rather than direct Supreme Court appeal under 28 U.S.C. §1253

Sec. 2, new §1304(e)(4)(A)–(H) · Privacy and Due Process — Includes the President and Vice President, cabinet, higher-paid Executive Office staff, political appointees, certain presidential special government employees, former appointees from the same presidency, close family of the President/Vice President/cabinet, and certain affiliated/controlled business entities. Not all federal employees are covered

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(1)–(3) · Government Power — Parties file settlement proposals in D.C. district court; the United States publishes them in the Federal Register and permits public comment. Written comments must be filed/published within 60 days. Relevant government-held settlement materials must generally be open to the public, except documents subject to federal privacy laws (e.g., Privacy Act/HIPAA), which must be filed under seal

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(4)(A)–(D) · Government Power — After the comment window, the panel considers comments; the United States responds publicly; parties submit detailed briefs, disputed/undisputed facts, evidence and communications. Shortening the normal 60-day window requires a court finding of extraordinary circumstances and no adverse public interest

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(5) · Government Power — Before approving a settlement, judges must find it not against the public interest and set aside proposals arbitrary/capricious, unconstitutional, ultra vires, procedurally unlawful, unsupported by the factual record, or unfair/collusive/excessive/unclear/unrelated to complaint claims

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(6)–(8) · Government Power — Permits testimony, experts, special masters, amicus participation and intervention, and review of comments. Requires disclosure to the court of parties’ communications. Stipulated facts may not be used as prima facie evidence or admitted without corroborating evidence in a different case. Drafting issue: paragraph (f)(6) refers to “paragraph (6)” when it apparently intends the review under paragraph (5); no assumed correction is scored

``(D) The Attorney General or his designee shall establish procedures to carry out the provisions of this subsection, but the 60- day period described in paragraph (2) may not be shortened except by order of the district court upon a showing that--

Sec. 2, new 31 U.S.C. §1304(e)(1)–(3) · Privacy and Due Process — Bars a covered person from receiving a monetary settlement or award of $250,000 or more, or any nonmonetary relief, unless they comply with the new process. Requires claims for that relief to be brought before a three-judge D.C. district court panel, notwithstanding 28 U.S.C. §1491, and sends panel judgments to the D.C. Circuit rather than direct Supreme Court appeal under 28 U.S.C. §1253

Sec. 2, new §1304(e)(4)(A)–(H) · Privacy and Due Process — Includes the President and Vice President, cabinet, higher-paid Executive Office staff, political appointees, certain presidential special government employees, former appointees from the same presidency, close family of the President/Vice President/cabinet, and certain affiliated/controlled business entities. Not all federal employees are covered

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(1)–(3) · Government Power — Parties file settlement proposals in D.C. district court; the United States publishes them in the Federal Register and permits public comment. Written comments must be filed/published within 60 days. Relevant government-held settlement materials must generally be open to the public, except documents subject to federal privacy laws (e.g., Privacy Act/HIPAA), which must be filed under seal

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(4)(A)–(D) · Government Power — After the comment window, the panel considers comments; the United States responds publicly; parties submit detailed briefs, disputed/undisputed facts, evidence and communications. Shortening the normal 60-day window requires a court finding of extraordinary circumstances and no adverse public interest

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(5) · Government Power — Before approving a settlement, judges must find it not against the public interest and set aside proposals arbitrary/capricious, unconstitutional, ultra vires, procedurally unlawful, unsupported by the factual record, or unfair/collusive/excessive/unclear/unrelated to complaint claims

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(6)–(8) · Government Power — Permits testimony, experts, special masters, amicus participation and intervention, and review of comments. Requires disclosure to the court of parties’ communications. Stipulated facts may not be used as prima facie evidence or admitted without corroborating evidence in a different case. Drafting issue: paragraph (f)(6) refers to “paragraph (6)” when it apparently intends the review under paragraph (5); no assumed correction is scored

``(i) extraordinary circumstances require such shortening; and

Sec. 2, new 31 U.S.C. §1304(e)(1)–(3) · Privacy and Due Process — Bars a covered person from receiving a monetary settlement or award of $250,000 or more, or any nonmonetary relief, unless they comply with the new process. Requires claims for that relief to be brought before a three-judge D.C. district court panel, notwithstanding 28 U.S.C. §1491, and sends panel judgments to the D.C. Circuit rather than direct Supreme Court appeal under 28 U.S.C. §1253

Sec. 2, new §1304(e)(4)(A)–(H) · Privacy and Due Process — Includes the President and Vice President, cabinet, higher-paid Executive Office staff, political appointees, certain presidential special government employees, former appointees from the same presidency, close family of the President/Vice President/cabinet, and certain affiliated/controlled business entities. Not all federal employees are covered

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(1)–(3) · Government Power — Parties file settlement proposals in D.C. district court; the United States publishes them in the Federal Register and permits public comment. Written comments must be filed/published within 60 days. Relevant government-held settlement materials must generally be open to the public, except documents subject to federal privacy laws (e.g., Privacy Act/HIPAA), which must be filed under seal

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(4)(A)–(D) · Government Power — After the comment window, the panel considers comments; the United States responds publicly; parties submit detailed briefs, disputed/undisputed facts, evidence and communications. Shortening the normal 60-day window requires a court finding of extraordinary circumstances and no adverse public interest

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(5) · Government Power — Before approving a settlement, judges must find it not against the public interest and set aside proposals arbitrary/capricious, unconstitutional, ultra vires, procedurally unlawful, unsupported by the factual record, or unfair/collusive/excessive/unclear/unrelated to complaint claims

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(6)–(8) · Government Power — Permits testimony, experts, special masters, amicus participation and intervention, and review of comments. Requires disclosure to the court of parties’ communications. Stipulated facts may not be used as prima facie evidence or admitted without corroborating evidence in a different case. Drafting issue: paragraph (f)(6) refers to “paragraph (6)” when it apparently intends the review under paragraph (5); no assumed correction is scored

``(ii) such shortening is not adverse to the public interest. ``(5)(A) Before entering any judgment approving a compromise settlement or award proposed by the United States under this section, the court shall-- ``(i) determine that the entry of such judgment is not against the public interest; and ``(ii) exercise judicial review of the proposal in accordance with subparagraph (B).

Sec. 2, new 31 U.S.C. §1304(e)(1)–(3) · Privacy and Due Process — Bars a covered person from receiving a monetary settlement or award of $250,000 or more, or any nonmonetary relief, unless they comply with the new process. Requires claims for that relief to be brought before a three-judge D.C. district court panel, notwithstanding 28 U.S.C. §1491, and sends panel judgments to the D.C. Circuit rather than direct Supreme Court appeal under 28 U.S.C. §1253

Sec. 2, new §1304(e)(4)(A)–(H) · Privacy and Due Process — Includes the President and Vice President, cabinet, higher-paid Executive Office staff, political appointees, certain presidential special government employees, former appointees from the same presidency, close family of the President/Vice President/cabinet, and certain affiliated/controlled business entities. Not all federal employees are covered

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(1)–(3) · Government Power — Parties file settlement proposals in D.C. district court; the United States publishes them in the Federal Register and permits public comment. Written comments must be filed/published within 60 days. Relevant government-held settlement materials must generally be open to the public, except documents subject to federal privacy laws (e.g., Privacy Act/HIPAA), which must be filed under seal

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(4)(A)–(D) · Government Power — After the comment window, the panel considers comments; the United States responds publicly; parties submit detailed briefs, disputed/undisputed facts, evidence and communications. Shortening the normal 60-day window requires a court finding of extraordinary circumstances and no adverse public interest

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(5) · Government Power — Before approving a settlement, judges must find it not against the public interest and set aside proposals arbitrary/capricious, unconstitutional, ultra vires, procedurally unlawful, unsupported by the factual record, or unfair/collusive/excessive/unclear/unrelated to complaint claims

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(6)–(8) · Government Power — Permits testimony, experts, special masters, amicus participation and intervention, and review of comments. Requires disclosure to the court of parties’ communications. Stipulated facts may not be used as prima facie evidence or admitted without corroborating evidence in a different case. Drafting issue: paragraph (f)(6) refers to “paragraph (6)” when it apparently intends the review under paragraph (5); no assumed correction is scored

``(B) The district court shall hold unlawful and set aside any proposal found to be--

Sec. 2, new 31 U.S.C. §1304(e)(1)–(3) · Privacy and Due Process — Bars a covered person from receiving a monetary settlement or award of $250,000 or more, or any nonmonetary relief, unless they comply with the new process. Requires claims for that relief to be brought before a three-judge D.C. district court panel, notwithstanding 28 U.S.C. §1491, and sends panel judgments to the D.C. Circuit rather than direct Supreme Court appeal under 28 U.S.C. §1253

Sec. 2, new §1304(e)(4)(A)–(H) · Privacy and Due Process — Includes the President and Vice President, cabinet, higher-paid Executive Office staff, political appointees, certain presidential special government employees, former appointees from the same presidency, close family of the President/Vice President/cabinet, and certain affiliated/controlled business entities. Not all federal employees are covered

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(1)–(3) · Government Power — Parties file settlement proposals in D.C. district court; the United States publishes them in the Federal Register and permits public comment. Written comments must be filed/published within 60 days. Relevant government-held settlement materials must generally be open to the public, except documents subject to federal privacy laws (e.g., Privacy Act/HIPAA), which must be filed under seal

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(4)(A)–(D) · Government Power — After the comment window, the panel considers comments; the United States responds publicly; parties submit detailed briefs, disputed/undisputed facts, evidence and communications. Shortening the normal 60-day window requires a court finding of extraordinary circumstances and no adverse public interest

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(5) · Government Power — Before approving a settlement, judges must find it not against the public interest and set aside proposals arbitrary/capricious, unconstitutional, ultra vires, procedurally unlawful, unsupported by the factual record, or unfair/collusive/excessive/unclear/unrelated to complaint claims

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(6)–(8) · Government Power — Permits testimony, experts, special masters, amicus participation and intervention, and review of comments. Requires disclosure to the court of parties’ communications. Stipulated facts may not be used as prima facie evidence or admitted without corroborating evidence in a different case. Drafting issue: paragraph (f)(6) refers to “paragraph (6)” when it apparently intends the review under paragraph (5); no assumed correction is scored

``(i) arbitrary, capricious, an abuse of discretion, or otherwise not in accordance with law;

Sec. 2, new 31 U.S.C. §1304(e)(1)–(3) · Privacy and Due Process — Bars a covered person from receiving a monetary settlement or award of $250,000 or more, or any nonmonetary relief, unless they comply with the new process. Requires claims for that relief to be brought before a three-judge D.C. district court panel, notwithstanding 28 U.S.C. §1491, and sends panel judgments to the D.C. Circuit rather than direct Supreme Court appeal under 28 U.S.C. §1253

Sec. 2, new §1304(e)(4)(A)–(H) · Privacy and Due Process — Includes the President and Vice President, cabinet, higher-paid Executive Office staff, political appointees, certain presidential special government employees, former appointees from the same presidency, close family of the President/Vice President/cabinet, and certain affiliated/controlled business entities. Not all federal employees are covered

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(1)–(3) · Government Power — Parties file settlement proposals in D.C. district court; the United States publishes them in the Federal Register and permits public comment. Written comments must be filed/published within 60 days. Relevant government-held settlement materials must generally be open to the public, except documents subject to federal privacy laws (e.g., Privacy Act/HIPAA), which must be filed under seal

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(4)(A)–(D) · Government Power — After the comment window, the panel considers comments; the United States responds publicly; parties submit detailed briefs, disputed/undisputed facts, evidence and communications. Shortening the normal 60-day window requires a court finding of extraordinary circumstances and no adverse public interest

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(5) · Government Power — Before approving a settlement, judges must find it not against the public interest and set aside proposals arbitrary/capricious, unconstitutional, ultra vires, procedurally unlawful, unsupported by the factual record, or unfair/collusive/excessive/unclear/unrelated to complaint claims

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(6)–(8) · Government Power — Permits testimony, experts, special masters, amicus participation and intervention, and review of comments. Requires disclosure to the court of parties’ communications. Stipulated facts may not be used as prima facie evidence or admitted without corroborating evidence in a different case. Drafting issue: paragraph (f)(6) refers to “paragraph (6)” when it apparently intends the review under paragraph (5); no assumed correction is scored

``(ii) contrary to constitutional right, power, privilege, or immunity;

Sec. 2, new 31 U.S.C. §1304(e)(1)–(3) · Privacy and Due Process — Bars a covered person from receiving a monetary settlement or award of $250,000 or more, or any nonmonetary relief, unless they comply with the new process. Requires claims for that relief to be brought before a three-judge D.C. district court panel, notwithstanding 28 U.S.C. §1491, and sends panel judgments to the D.C. Circuit rather than direct Supreme Court appeal under 28 U.S.C. §1253

Sec. 2, new §1304(e)(4)(A)–(H) · Privacy and Due Process — Includes the President and Vice President, cabinet, higher-paid Executive Office staff, political appointees, certain presidential special government employees, former appointees from the same presidency, close family of the President/Vice President/cabinet, and certain affiliated/controlled business entities. Not all federal employees are covered

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(1)–(3) · Government Power — Parties file settlement proposals in D.C. district court; the United States publishes them in the Federal Register and permits public comment. Written comments must be filed/published within 60 days. Relevant government-held settlement materials must generally be open to the public, except documents subject to federal privacy laws (e.g., Privacy Act/HIPAA), which must be filed under seal

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(4)(A)–(D) · Government Power — After the comment window, the panel considers comments; the United States responds publicly; parties submit detailed briefs, disputed/undisputed facts, evidence and communications. Shortening the normal 60-day window requires a court finding of extraordinary circumstances and no adverse public interest

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(5) · Government Power — Before approving a settlement, judges must find it not against the public interest and set aside proposals arbitrary/capricious, unconstitutional, ultra vires, procedurally unlawful, unsupported by the factual record, or unfair/collusive/excessive/unclear/unrelated to complaint claims

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(6)–(8) · Government Power — Permits testimony, experts, special masters, amicus participation and intervention, and review of comments. Requires disclosure to the court of parties’ communications. Stipulated facts may not be used as prima facie evidence or admitted without corroborating evidence in a different case. Drafting issue: paragraph (f)(6) refers to “paragraph (6)” when it apparently intends the review under paragraph (5); no assumed correction is scored

``(iii) in excess of statutory jurisdiction, authority, or limitations, or short of statutory right;

Sec. 2, new 31 U.S.C. §1304(e)(1)–(3) · Privacy and Due Process — Bars a covered person from receiving a monetary settlement or award of $250,000 or more, or any nonmonetary relief, unless they comply with the new process. Requires claims for that relief to be brought before a three-judge D.C. district court panel, notwithstanding 28 U.S.C. §1491, and sends panel judgments to the D.C. Circuit rather than direct Supreme Court appeal under 28 U.S.C. §1253

Sec. 2, new §1304(e)(4)(A)–(H) · Privacy and Due Process — Includes the President and Vice President, cabinet, higher-paid Executive Office staff, political appointees, certain presidential special government employees, former appointees from the same presidency, close family of the President/Vice President/cabinet, and certain affiliated/controlled business entities. Not all federal employees are covered

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(1)–(3) · Government Power — Parties file settlement proposals in D.C. district court; the United States publishes them in the Federal Register and permits public comment. Written comments must be filed/published within 60 days. Relevant government-held settlement materials must generally be open to the public, except documents subject to federal privacy laws (e.g., Privacy Act/HIPAA), which must be filed under seal

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(4)(A)–(D) · Government Power — After the comment window, the panel considers comments; the United States responds publicly; parties submit detailed briefs, disputed/undisputed facts, evidence and communications. Shortening the normal 60-day window requires a court finding of extraordinary circumstances and no adverse public interest

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(5) · Government Power — Before approving a settlement, judges must find it not against the public interest and set aside proposals arbitrary/capricious, unconstitutional, ultra vires, procedurally unlawful, unsupported by the factual record, or unfair/collusive/excessive/unclear/unrelated to complaint claims

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(6)–(8) · Government Power — Permits testimony, experts, special masters, amicus participation and intervention, and review of comments. Requires disclosure to the court of parties’ communications. Stipulated facts may not be used as prima facie evidence or admitted without corroborating evidence in a different case. Drafting issue: paragraph (f)(6) refers to “paragraph (6)” when it apparently intends the review under paragraph (5); no assumed correction is scored

``(iv) without observance of procedure required by law;

Sec. 2, new 31 U.S.C. §1304(e)(1)–(3) · Privacy and Due Process — Bars a covered person from receiving a monetary settlement or award of $250,000 or more, or any nonmonetary relief, unless they comply with the new process. Requires claims for that relief to be brought before a three-judge D.C. district court panel, notwithstanding 28 U.S.C. §1491, and sends panel judgments to the D.C. Circuit rather than direct Supreme Court appeal under 28 U.S.C. §1253

Sec. 2, new §1304(e)(4)(A)–(H) · Privacy and Due Process — Includes the President and Vice President, cabinet, higher-paid Executive Office staff, political appointees, certain presidential special government employees, former appointees from the same presidency, close family of the President/Vice President/cabinet, and certain affiliated/controlled business entities. Not all federal employees are covered

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(1)–(3) · Government Power — Parties file settlement proposals in D.C. district court; the United States publishes them in the Federal Register and permits public comment. Written comments must be filed/published within 60 days. Relevant government-held settlement materials must generally be open to the public, except documents subject to federal privacy laws (e.g., Privacy Act/HIPAA), which must be filed under seal

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(4)(A)–(D) · Government Power — After the comment window, the panel considers comments; the United States responds publicly; parties submit detailed briefs, disputed/undisputed facts, evidence and communications. Shortening the normal 60-day window requires a court finding of extraordinary circumstances and no adverse public interest

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(5) · Government Power — Before approving a settlement, judges must find it not against the public interest and set aside proposals arbitrary/capricious, unconstitutional, ultra vires, procedurally unlawful, unsupported by the factual record, or unfair/collusive/excessive/unclear/unrelated to complaint claims

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(6)–(8) · Government Power — Permits testimony, experts, special masters, amicus participation and intervention, and review of comments. Requires disclosure to the court of parties’ communications. Stipulated facts may not be used as prima facie evidence or admitted without corroborating evidence in a different case. Drafting issue: paragraph (f)(6) refers to “paragraph (6)” when it apparently intends the review under paragraph (5); no assumed correction is scored

``(v) unwarranted by the facts in the record, including those facts noted during the public comment period or provided via amicus brief, and which the court deems to be credible; or

Sec. 2, new 31 U.S.C. §1304(e)(1)–(3) · Privacy and Due Process — Bars a covered person from receiving a monetary settlement or award of $250,000 or more, or any nonmonetary relief, unless they comply with the new process. Requires claims for that relief to be brought before a three-judge D.C. district court panel, notwithstanding 28 U.S.C. §1491, and sends panel judgments to the D.C. Circuit rather than direct Supreme Court appeal under 28 U.S.C. §1253

Sec. 2, new §1304(e)(4)(A)–(H) · Privacy and Due Process — Includes the President and Vice President, cabinet, higher-paid Executive Office staff, political appointees, certain presidential special government employees, former appointees from the same presidency, close family of the President/Vice President/cabinet, and certain affiliated/controlled business entities. Not all federal employees are covered

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(1)–(3) · Government Power — Parties file settlement proposals in D.C. district court; the United States publishes them in the Federal Register and permits public comment. Written comments must be filed/published within 60 days. Relevant government-held settlement materials must generally be open to the public, except documents subject to federal privacy laws (e.g., Privacy Act/HIPAA), which must be filed under seal

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(4)(A)–(D) · Government Power — After the comment window, the panel considers comments; the United States responds publicly; parties submit detailed briefs, disputed/undisputed facts, evidence and communications. Shortening the normal 60-day window requires a court finding of extraordinary circumstances and no adverse public interest

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(5) · Government Power — Before approving a settlement, judges must find it not against the public interest and set aside proposals arbitrary/capricious, unconstitutional, ultra vires, procedurally unlawful, unsupported by the factual record, or unfair/collusive/excessive/unclear/unrelated to complaint claims

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(6)–(8) · Government Power — Permits testimony, experts, special masters, amicus participation and intervention, and review of comments. Requires disclosure to the court of parties’ communications. Stipulated facts may not be used as prima facie evidence or admitted without corroborating evidence in a different case. Drafting issue: paragraph (f)(6) refers to “paragraph (6)” when it apparently intends the review under paragraph (5); no assumed correction is scored

``(vi) unfair for reasons that may include-- ``(I) the settlement being tainted by improper collusion or corruption of any kind; ``(II) the award being in excess of what a non- covered plaintiff would reasonably expect to receive under the same circumstances; ``(III) the terms of the settlement, including its enforcement mechanism, being unclear; or ``(IV) the settlement failing to reflect a resolution of the claims in the complaint.

Sec. 2, new 31 U.S.C. §1304(e)(1)–(3) · Privacy and Due Process — Bars a covered person from receiving a monetary settlement or award of $250,000 or more, or any nonmonetary relief, unless they comply with the new process. Requires claims for that relief to be brought before a three-judge D.C. district court panel, notwithstanding 28 U.S.C. §1491, and sends panel judgments to the D.C. Circuit rather than direct Supreme Court appeal under 28 U.S.C. §1253

Sec. 2, new §1304(e)(4)(A)–(H) · Privacy and Due Process — Includes the President and Vice President, cabinet, higher-paid Executive Office staff, political appointees, certain presidential special government employees, former appointees from the same presidency, close family of the President/Vice President/cabinet, and certain affiliated/controlled business entities. Not all federal employees are covered

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(1)–(3) · Government Power — Parties file settlement proposals in D.C. district court; the United States publishes them in the Federal Register and permits public comment. Written comments must be filed/published within 60 days. Relevant government-held settlement materials must generally be open to the public, except documents subject to federal privacy laws (e.g., Privacy Act/HIPAA), which must be filed under seal

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(4)(A)–(D) · Government Power — After the comment window, the panel considers comments; the United States responds publicly; parties submit detailed briefs, disputed/undisputed facts, evidence and communications. Shortening the normal 60-day window requires a court finding of extraordinary circumstances and no adverse public interest

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(5) · Government Power — Before approving a settlement, judges must find it not against the public interest and set aside proposals arbitrary/capricious, unconstitutional, ultra vires, procedurally unlawful, unsupported by the factual record, or unfair/collusive/excessive/unclear/unrelated to complaint claims

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(6)–(8) · Government Power — Permits testimony, experts, special masters, amicus participation and intervention, and review of comments. Requires disclosure to the court of parties’ communications. Stipulated facts may not be used as prima facie evidence or admitted without corroborating evidence in a different case. Drafting issue: paragraph (f)(6) refers to “paragraph (6)” when it apparently intends the review under paragraph (5); no assumed correction is scored

``(6) In making a determination under paragraph (6), the court may--

Sec. 2, new 31 U.S.C. §1304(e)(1)–(3) · Privacy and Due Process — Bars a covered person from receiving a monetary settlement or award of $250,000 or more, or any nonmonetary relief, unless they comply with the new process. Requires claims for that relief to be brought before a three-judge D.C. district court panel, notwithstanding 28 U.S.C. §1491, and sends panel judgments to the D.C. Circuit rather than direct Supreme Court appeal under 28 U.S.C. §1253

Sec. 2, new §1304(e)(4)(A)–(H) · Privacy and Due Process — Includes the President and Vice President, cabinet, higher-paid Executive Office staff, political appointees, certain presidential special government employees, former appointees from the same presidency, close family of the President/Vice President/cabinet, and certain affiliated/controlled business entities. Not all federal employees are covered

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(1)–(3) · Government Power — Parties file settlement proposals in D.C. district court; the United States publishes them in the Federal Register and permits public comment. Written comments must be filed/published within 60 days. Relevant government-held settlement materials must generally be open to the public, except documents subject to federal privacy laws (e.g., Privacy Act/HIPAA), which must be filed under seal

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(4)(A)–(D) · Government Power — After the comment window, the panel considers comments; the United States responds publicly; parties submit detailed briefs, disputed/undisputed facts, evidence and communications. Shortening the normal 60-day window requires a court finding of extraordinary circumstances and no adverse public interest

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(5) · Government Power — Before approving a settlement, judges must find it not against the public interest and set aside proposals arbitrary/capricious, unconstitutional, ultra vires, procedurally unlawful, unsupported by the factual record, or unfair/collusive/excessive/unclear/unrelated to complaint claims

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(6)–(8) · Government Power — Permits testimony, experts, special masters, amicus participation and intervention, and review of comments. Requires disclosure to the court of parties’ communications. Stipulated facts may not be used as prima facie evidence or admitted without corroborating evidence in a different case. Drafting issue: paragraph (f)(6) refers to “paragraph (6)” when it apparently intends the review under paragraph (5); no assumed correction is scored

``(A) take testimony of Government officials or experts or such other expert witnesses, upon motion of any party or participant or upon its own motion, as the court may deem appropriate;

Sec. 2, new 31 U.S.C. §1304(e)(1)–(3) · Privacy and Due Process — Bars a covered person from receiving a monetary settlement or award of $250,000 or more, or any nonmonetary relief, unless they comply with the new process. Requires claims for that relief to be brought before a three-judge D.C. district court panel, notwithstanding 28 U.S.C. §1491, and sends panel judgments to the D.C. Circuit rather than direct Supreme Court appeal under 28 U.S.C. §1253

Sec. 2, new §1304(e)(4)(A)–(H) · Privacy and Due Process — Includes the President and Vice President, cabinet, higher-paid Executive Office staff, political appointees, certain presidential special government employees, former appointees from the same presidency, close family of the President/Vice President/cabinet, and certain affiliated/controlled business entities. Not all federal employees are covered

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(1)–(3) · Government Power — Parties file settlement proposals in D.C. district court; the United States publishes them in the Federal Register and permits public comment. Written comments must be filed/published within 60 days. Relevant government-held settlement materials must generally be open to the public, except documents subject to federal privacy laws (e.g., Privacy Act/HIPAA), which must be filed under seal

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(4)(A)–(D) · Government Power — After the comment window, the panel considers comments; the United States responds publicly; parties submit detailed briefs, disputed/undisputed facts, evidence and communications. Shortening the normal 60-day window requires a court finding of extraordinary circumstances and no adverse public interest

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(5) · Government Power — Before approving a settlement, judges must find it not against the public interest and set aside proposals arbitrary/capricious, unconstitutional, ultra vires, procedurally unlawful, unsupported by the factual record, or unfair/collusive/excessive/unclear/unrelated to complaint claims

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(6)–(8) · Government Power — Permits testimony, experts, special masters, amicus participation and intervention, and review of comments. Requires disclosure to the court of parties’ communications. Stipulated facts may not be used as prima facie evidence or admitted without corroborating evidence in a different case. Drafting issue: paragraph (f)(6) refers to “paragraph (6)” when it apparently intends the review under paragraph (5); no assumed correction is scored

``(B) appoint a special master and such outside consultants or expert witnesses as the court may deem appropriate;

Sec. 2, new 31 U.S.C. §1304(e)(1)–(3) · Privacy and Due Process — Bars a covered person from receiving a monetary settlement or award of $250,000 or more, or any nonmonetary relief, unless they comply with the new process. Requires claims for that relief to be brought before a three-judge D.C. district court panel, notwithstanding 28 U.S.C. §1491, and sends panel judgments to the D.C. Circuit rather than direct Supreme Court appeal under 28 U.S.C. §1253

Sec. 2, new §1304(e)(4)(A)–(H) · Privacy and Due Process — Includes the President and Vice President, cabinet, higher-paid Executive Office staff, political appointees, certain presidential special government employees, former appointees from the same presidency, close family of the President/Vice President/cabinet, and certain affiliated/controlled business entities. Not all federal employees are covered

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(1)–(3) · Government Power — Parties file settlement proposals in D.C. district court; the United States publishes them in the Federal Register and permits public comment. Written comments must be filed/published within 60 days. Relevant government-held settlement materials must generally be open to the public, except documents subject to federal privacy laws (e.g., Privacy Act/HIPAA), which must be filed under seal

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(4)(A)–(D) · Government Power — After the comment window, the panel considers comments; the United States responds publicly; parties submit detailed briefs, disputed/undisputed facts, evidence and communications. Shortening the normal 60-day window requires a court finding of extraordinary circumstances and no adverse public interest

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(5) · Government Power — Before approving a settlement, judges must find it not against the public interest and set aside proposals arbitrary/capricious, unconstitutional, ultra vires, procedurally unlawful, unsupported by the factual record, or unfair/collusive/excessive/unclear/unrelated to complaint claims

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(6)–(8) · Government Power — Permits testimony, experts, special masters, amicus participation and intervention, and review of comments. Requires disclosure to the court of parties’ communications. Stipulated facts may not be used as prima facie evidence or admitted without corroborating evidence in a different case. Drafting issue: paragraph (f)(6) refers to “paragraph (6)” when it apparently intends the review under paragraph (5); no assumed correction is scored

``(C) compel and obtain the views, evaluations, or advice of any individual, group or agency of government with respect to any aspects of the proposed judgment or the effect of such judgment, in such manner as the court deems appropriate;

Sec. 2, new 31 U.S.C. §1304(e)(1)–(3) · Privacy and Due Process — Bars a covered person from receiving a monetary settlement or award of $250,000 or more, or any nonmonetary relief, unless they comply with the new process. Requires claims for that relief to be brought before a three-judge D.C. district court panel, notwithstanding 28 U.S.C. §1491, and sends panel judgments to the D.C. Circuit rather than direct Supreme Court appeal under 28 U.S.C. §1253

Sec. 2, new §1304(e)(4)(A)–(H) · Privacy and Due Process — Includes the President and Vice President, cabinet, higher-paid Executive Office staff, political appointees, certain presidential special government employees, former appointees from the same presidency, close family of the President/Vice President/cabinet, and certain affiliated/controlled business entities. Not all federal employees are covered

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(1)–(3) · Government Power — Parties file settlement proposals in D.C. district court; the United States publishes them in the Federal Register and permits public comment. Written comments must be filed/published within 60 days. Relevant government-held settlement materials must generally be open to the public, except documents subject to federal privacy laws (e.g., Privacy Act/HIPAA), which must be filed under seal

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(4)(A)–(D) · Government Power — After the comment window, the panel considers comments; the United States responds publicly; parties submit detailed briefs, disputed/undisputed facts, evidence and communications. Shortening the normal 60-day window requires a court finding of extraordinary circumstances and no adverse public interest

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(5) · Government Power — Before approving a settlement, judges must find it not against the public interest and set aside proposals arbitrary/capricious, unconstitutional, ultra vires, procedurally unlawful, unsupported by the factual record, or unfair/collusive/excessive/unclear/unrelated to complaint claims

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(6)–(8) · Government Power — Permits testimony, experts, special masters, amicus participation and intervention, and review of comments. Requires disclosure to the court of parties’ communications. Stipulated facts may not be used as prima facie evidence or admitted without corroborating evidence in a different case. Drafting issue: paragraph (f)(6) refers to “paragraph (6)” when it apparently intends the review under paragraph (5); no assumed correction is scored

``(D) authorize full or limited participation in proceedings before the court by interested persons or agencies, including appearance amicus curiae, intervention as a party pursuant to the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, examination of witnesses or documentary materials, or participation in any other manner and extent which serves the public interest as the court may deem appropriate;

Sec. 2, new 31 U.S.C. §1304(e)(1)–(3) · Privacy and Due Process — Bars a covered person from receiving a monetary settlement or award of $250,000 or more, or any nonmonetary relief, unless they comply with the new process. Requires claims for that relief to be brought before a three-judge D.C. district court panel, notwithstanding 28 U.S.C. §1491, and sends panel judgments to the D.C. Circuit rather than direct Supreme Court appeal under 28 U.S.C. §1253

Sec. 2, new §1304(e)(4)(A)–(H) · Privacy and Due Process — Includes the President and Vice President, cabinet, higher-paid Executive Office staff, political appointees, certain presidential special government employees, former appointees from the same presidency, close family of the President/Vice President/cabinet, and certain affiliated/controlled business entities. Not all federal employees are covered

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(1)–(3) · Government Power — Parties file settlement proposals in D.C. district court; the United States publishes them in the Federal Register and permits public comment. Written comments must be filed/published within 60 days. Relevant government-held settlement materials must generally be open to the public, except documents subject to federal privacy laws (e.g., Privacy Act/HIPAA), which must be filed under seal

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(4)(A)–(D) · Government Power — After the comment window, the panel considers comments; the United States responds publicly; parties submit detailed briefs, disputed/undisputed facts, evidence and communications. Shortening the normal 60-day window requires a court finding of extraordinary circumstances and no adverse public interest

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(5) · Government Power — Before approving a settlement, judges must find it not against the public interest and set aside proposals arbitrary/capricious, unconstitutional, ultra vires, procedurally unlawful, unsupported by the factual record, or unfair/collusive/excessive/unclear/unrelated to complaint claims

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(6)–(8) · Government Power — Permits testimony, experts, special masters, amicus participation and intervention, and review of comments. Requires disclosure to the court of parties’ communications. Stipulated facts may not be used as prima facie evidence or admitted without corroborating evidence in a different case. Drafting issue: paragraph (f)(6) refers to “paragraph (6)” when it apparently intends the review under paragraph (5); no assumed correction is scored

``(E) review any comments including any objections filed with the United States under paragraph (4) concerning the proposed judgment and the responses of the United States to such comments and objections; and

Sec. 2, new 31 U.S.C. §1304(e)(1)–(3) · Privacy and Due Process — Bars a covered person from receiving a monetary settlement or award of $250,000 or more, or any nonmonetary relief, unless they comply with the new process. Requires claims for that relief to be brought before a three-judge D.C. district court panel, notwithstanding 28 U.S.C. §1491, and sends panel judgments to the D.C. Circuit rather than direct Supreme Court appeal under 28 U.S.C. §1253

Sec. 2, new §1304(e)(4)(A)–(H) · Privacy and Due Process — Includes the President and Vice President, cabinet, higher-paid Executive Office staff, political appointees, certain presidential special government employees, former appointees from the same presidency, close family of the President/Vice President/cabinet, and certain affiliated/controlled business entities. Not all federal employees are covered

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(1)–(3) · Government Power — Parties file settlement proposals in D.C. district court; the United States publishes them in the Federal Register and permits public comment. Written comments must be filed/published within 60 days. Relevant government-held settlement materials must generally be open to the public, except documents subject to federal privacy laws (e.g., Privacy Act/HIPAA), which must be filed under seal

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(4)(A)–(D) · Government Power — After the comment window, the panel considers comments; the United States responds publicly; parties submit detailed briefs, disputed/undisputed facts, evidence and communications. Shortening the normal 60-day window requires a court finding of extraordinary circumstances and no adverse public interest

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(5) · Government Power — Before approving a settlement, judges must find it not against the public interest and set aside proposals arbitrary/capricious, unconstitutional, ultra vires, procedurally unlawful, unsupported by the factual record, or unfair/collusive/excessive/unclear/unrelated to complaint claims

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(6)–(8) · Government Power — Permits testimony, experts, special masters, amicus participation and intervention, and review of comments. Requires disclosure to the court of parties’ communications. Stipulated facts may not be used as prima facie evidence or admitted without corroborating evidence in a different case. Drafting issue: paragraph (f)(6) refers to “paragraph (6)” when it apparently intends the review under paragraph (5); no assumed correction is scored

``(F) take such other action in the public interest as the court may deem appropriate.

Sec. 2, new 31 U.S.C. §1304(e)(1)–(3) · Privacy and Due Process — Bars a covered person from receiving a monetary settlement or award of $250,000 or more, or any nonmonetary relief, unless they comply with the new process. Requires claims for that relief to be brought before a three-judge D.C. district court panel, notwithstanding 28 U.S.C. §1491, and sends panel judgments to the D.C. Circuit rather than direct Supreme Court appeal under 28 U.S.C. §1253

Sec. 2, new §1304(e)(4)(A)–(H) · Privacy and Due Process — Includes the President and Vice President, cabinet, higher-paid Executive Office staff, political appointees, certain presidential special government employees, former appointees from the same presidency, close family of the President/Vice President/cabinet, and certain affiliated/controlled business entities. Not all federal employees are covered

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(1)–(3) · Government Power — Parties file settlement proposals in D.C. district court; the United States publishes them in the Federal Register and permits public comment. Written comments must be filed/published within 60 days. Relevant government-held settlement materials must generally be open to the public, except documents subject to federal privacy laws (e.g., Privacy Act/HIPAA), which must be filed under seal

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(4)(A)–(D) · Government Power — After the comment window, the panel considers comments; the United States responds publicly; parties submit detailed briefs, disputed/undisputed facts, evidence and communications. Shortening the normal 60-day window requires a court finding of extraordinary circumstances and no adverse public interest

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(5) · Government Power — Before approving a settlement, judges must find it not against the public interest and set aside proposals arbitrary/capricious, unconstitutional, ultra vires, procedurally unlawful, unsupported by the factual record, or unfair/collusive/excessive/unclear/unrelated to complaint claims

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(6)–(8) · Government Power — Permits testimony, experts, special masters, amicus participation and intervention, and review of comments. Requires disclosure to the court of parties’ communications. Stipulated facts may not be used as prima facie evidence or admitted without corroborating evidence in a different case. Drafting issue: paragraph (f)(6) refers to “paragraph (6)” when it apparently intends the review under paragraph (5); no assumed correction is scored

``(7) At the time of the filing of any proposal for a compromise settlement or award under paragraph (1), each party shall file with the district court a description of the adversity underlying the suit and details of any and all communications between the parties.

Sec. 2, new 31 U.S.C. §1304(e)(1)–(3) · Privacy and Due Process — Bars a covered person from receiving a monetary settlement or award of $250,000 or more, or any nonmonetary relief, unless they comply with the new process. Requires claims for that relief to be brought before a three-judge D.C. district court panel, notwithstanding 28 U.S.C. §1491, and sends panel judgments to the D.C. Circuit rather than direct Supreme Court appeal under 28 U.S.C. §1253

Sec. 2, new §1304(e)(4)(A)–(H) · Privacy and Due Process — Includes the President and Vice President, cabinet, higher-paid Executive Office staff, political appointees, certain presidential special government employees, former appointees from the same presidency, close family of the President/Vice President/cabinet, and certain affiliated/controlled business entities. Not all federal employees are covered

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(1)–(3) · Government Power — Parties file settlement proposals in D.C. district court; the United States publishes them in the Federal Register and permits public comment. Written comments must be filed/published within 60 days. Relevant government-held settlement materials must generally be open to the public, except documents subject to federal privacy laws (e.g., Privacy Act/HIPAA), which must be filed under seal

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(4)(A)–(D) · Government Power — After the comment window, the panel considers comments; the United States responds publicly; parties submit detailed briefs, disputed/undisputed facts, evidence and communications. Shortening the normal 60-day window requires a court finding of extraordinary circumstances and no adverse public interest

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(5) · Government Power — Before approving a settlement, judges must find it not against the public interest and set aside proposals arbitrary/capricious, unconstitutional, ultra vires, procedurally unlawful, unsupported by the factual record, or unfair/collusive/excessive/unclear/unrelated to complaint claims

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(6)–(8) · Government Power — Permits testimony, experts, special masters, amicus participation and intervention, and review of comments. Requires disclosure to the court of parties’ communications. Stipulated facts may not be used as prima facie evidence or admitted without corroborating evidence in a different case. Drafting issue: paragraph (f)(6) refers to “paragraph (6)” when it apparently intends the review under paragraph (5); no assumed correction is scored

``(8) Any fact stipulated as part of a suit brought in accordance with this subsection--

Sec. 2, new 31 U.S.C. §1304(e)(1)–(3) · Privacy and Due Process — Bars a covered person from receiving a monetary settlement or award of $250,000 or more, or any nonmonetary relief, unless they comply with the new process. Requires claims for that relief to be brought before a three-judge D.C. district court panel, notwithstanding 28 U.S.C. §1491, and sends panel judgments to the D.C. Circuit rather than direct Supreme Court appeal under 28 U.S.C. §1253

Sec. 2, new §1304(e)(4)(A)–(H) · Privacy and Due Process — Includes the President and Vice President, cabinet, higher-paid Executive Office staff, political appointees, certain presidential special government employees, former appointees from the same presidency, close family of the President/Vice President/cabinet, and certain affiliated/controlled business entities. Not all federal employees are covered

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(1)–(3) · Government Power — Parties file settlement proposals in D.C. district court; the United States publishes them in the Federal Register and permits public comment. Written comments must be filed/published within 60 days. Relevant government-held settlement materials must generally be open to the public, except documents subject to federal privacy laws (e.g., Privacy Act/HIPAA), which must be filed under seal

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(4)(A)–(D) · Government Power — After the comment window, the panel considers comments; the United States responds publicly; parties submit detailed briefs, disputed/undisputed facts, evidence and communications. Shortening the normal 60-day window requires a court finding of extraordinary circumstances and no adverse public interest

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(5) · Government Power — Before approving a settlement, judges must find it not against the public interest and set aside proposals arbitrary/capricious, unconstitutional, ultra vires, procedurally unlawful, unsupported by the factual record, or unfair/collusive/excessive/unclear/unrelated to complaint claims

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(6)–(8) · Government Power — Permits testimony, experts, special masters, amicus participation and intervention, and review of comments. Requires disclosure to the court of parties’ communications. Stipulated facts may not be used as prima facie evidence or admitted without corroborating evidence in a different case. Drafting issue: paragraph (f)(6) refers to “paragraph (6)” when it apparently intends the review under paragraph (5); no assumed correction is scored

``(A) shall only be admissible against a party to such suit in another action or proceeding if there is sufficient evidence to support such stipulated fact; and

Sec. 2, new 31 U.S.C. §1304(e)(1)–(3) · Privacy and Due Process — Bars a covered person from receiving a monetary settlement or award of $250,000 or more, or any nonmonetary relief, unless they comply with the new process. Requires claims for that relief to be brought before a three-judge D.C. district court panel, notwithstanding 28 U.S.C. §1491, and sends panel judgments to the D.C. Circuit rather than direct Supreme Court appeal under 28 U.S.C. §1253

Sec. 2, new §1304(e)(4)(A)–(H) · Privacy and Due Process — Includes the President and Vice President, cabinet, higher-paid Executive Office staff, political appointees, certain presidential special government employees, former appointees from the same presidency, close family of the President/Vice President/cabinet, and certain affiliated/controlled business entities. Not all federal employees are covered

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(1)–(3) · Government Power — Parties file settlement proposals in D.C. district court; the United States publishes them in the Federal Register and permits public comment. Written comments must be filed/published within 60 days. Relevant government-held settlement materials must generally be open to the public, except documents subject to federal privacy laws (e.g., Privacy Act/HIPAA), which must be filed under seal

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(4)(A)–(D) · Government Power — After the comment window, the panel considers comments; the United States responds publicly; parties submit detailed briefs, disputed/undisputed facts, evidence and communications. Shortening the normal 60-day window requires a court finding of extraordinary circumstances and no adverse public interest

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(5) · Government Power — Before approving a settlement, judges must find it not against the public interest and set aside proposals arbitrary/capricious, unconstitutional, ultra vires, procedurally unlawful, unsupported by the factual record, or unfair/collusive/excessive/unclear/unrelated to complaint claims

Sec. 2, new §1304(f)(6)–(8) · Government Power — Permits testimony, experts, special masters, amicus participation and intervention, and review of comments. Requires disclosure to the court of parties’ communications. Stipulated facts may not be used as prima facie evidence or admitted without corroborating evidence in a different case. Drafting issue: paragraph (f)(6) refers to “paragraph (6)” when it apparently intends the review under paragraph (5); no assumed correction is scored

``(B) does not constitute prima facie evidence against such party in any such action or proceeding.''. <all>

Findings source: bill-scores-v2-batch45-findings-2026-11-15.md. Highlights come only from that file; no finding, score, or provision was invented for this page.

What you can do

Contact your U.S. Representative and Senators about this bill.

Find your Representative Contact your Senators

Spot an error on this page? Report it.